Politics Thread!

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Harlequin »

tufty wrote:Only if they can state that they are also a friend and can recognise you from a photo. However, the list of those able to countersign is not all that short (or even exhaustive, it's a list of examples of recognised professions

Code: Select all

Recognised professions
…
Out of all those, the only current personal friends who seem to fit are professional photographers.

RiK, could you sign a piccy of me?
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
phattslagg
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3578
Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
Location: Worcester, England

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by phattslagg »

@tufty If you don’t think that this will mean significant numbers of people will end up not being able to vote in the next GE, then I really don’t know what to say.

The “passports are only really £8 a year” is already one of the most gobsmackingly privileged (and downright stupid) comments I’ve seen on here, and now you seem to be genuinely defending the blatant disenfranchisement of potentially millions of voters.

The tories are doing this for one reason only: to make it harder for people who are more likely to vote against them to vote. And here you are defending them.
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by gilesgoat »

I think here you are confusing ( intentionally ? ) the idea of "free" with the idea of "providing an identification when necessary" ( for example to avoid you voting in the name/place of someone else by lying on your identity ).

In essence, in Italy at least, the ID when you vote is to avoid me for example going in place of you saying I am you and I am goign to vote ( again ) what *I* like.

This, in Italy, would happen "all the time" without at least a minimal form of "control" in place, I don't think ( apart those with true nefarious inentions ) would ever complain about "why I need an ID to vote".

Also you need to prove "you are Italian citizen" to be allowed to vote, foreing people normall don't have right to vote in Italy except for some local things.
Sono elettori tutti i cittadini, uomini e donne, che hanno raggiunto la maggiore età.

Il voto è personale ed eguale, libero e segreto. Il suo esercizio è dovere civico.

Il diritto di voto non può essere limitato se non per incapacità civile o per effetto di sentenza penale irrevocabile o nei casi di indegnità morale indicati dalla legge.
Says "all women and men CITIZENS of LEGAL AGE ( 18 ) can vote. The vote is personal,secret,free . Voting is a CIVIC DUTY !"

Which means "you can NOT invent excuses NOT to vote".

"The right to vote can't be limited unless incapacity or via sentence or in case of moral indignity indicated by laws".

All the stories about "witnesses to sign for a passport/ids" .. would not ever EVER work in Italy, you'd have people "swearing to God you are Napoleon" and such.

It's much simpler, you don't need any of all that.

You go to your country hall in the "anagrafe registar" of the town you are resident in and you ask for an ID, they'll provide you with the necessary paperwork that you can sort out on the spot, all you need to provide is a picture, normally there's a pic booth in there as well.

Mind you, in that place, provided you provided the correct info and can be verified, the probably know "more of you than what you know of yourself",if they start digging on the records.

Passport is a completely different story, being a paper that allows you to go in/out the country ( and you could be a convicted trying to escape ) then it's a matter of immigration/security, in fact it's issued by Carabinieri alone. You go to a Carabinieri station and you apply for a passport, it's not a quick matter, it never been, everyone in Italy knows, it is what it is, it has a cost, everyone knows that.

Hoever is mostly to go in/out non-eu countries, for EU nowdays you don't need anything. Lot of peole don't have a passport in Italy because they never needed one, but practically EVERYONE has at least some form of ID ( ID card, driving license, NHS card, something ) you just CANNOT live in Italy without one.

I repeat "the basic of all this is INCREDIBLY SIMPLE" "you can NOT take - in Italy - just at pure face value what anyone is saying you" especially when what that really matters it needs to be backed up by "at least something that proves you did not just listen and took for granted what he/she said".

Italy is "the land of papers", everyhing MUST be in some paper form, it's also the land of "scripta tenet, verba volant" ( i.e. writing keeps, words fly away ) "by voice" stuff has practically ZERO legal value in Italy.

"Free" in Italy ( and many other places ) does NOT mean you are "free to do what you want when you want", you are "free" within the limitations of the laws in act, you are NOT free to lie about your identity when required by law for example, that's a freedom we don't have.

Heck you are not even free to put a banner saying "the politician X is crap don't vote for it", some people did in the last election, "secret services" ( Digos ) immeditaly came out and took it down treatening arrest.

But anyway, it's Italy, I can GUARANTEE you will NOT vote in Italy WITHOUT an identification and you DO NOT go to the poll station simply saying "I am mr X let me vote" without any document proving it.

Anyway you go to the town hall, you pay 20 eur, job done, it's going to last you 5 years, then you'll need another 15 eur or so for the next 5 years.

"If you can't afford that, then you are not alive", I am quite sure social services can provide you an ID even if you really can't afford that.

Again 5 years .. 10 years .. 1 year .. I need to renew this .. in Italy "it is as it is, it works like that" .. you could always try to vote someone else in the next election that wants to change those laws but as long as the laws are like that it is what it is ...

And if you think that "needing an ID to vote" in Italy "is a mega pain in the arse/excludes people" .. "you are NOT made to live in Italy" .. you should see all it takes to do ANYTHING in Italy .. ONE PAPER ONLY ???!!! JUST AN ID ??!!.. that's TOO EASY !! I need 15 papers at least + 1 unobtainable one.

Italy : "if it's too simple, it needs to get more complex, if it's not complex enough we can't twist it" ..
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
venusian
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6653
Joined: Wed Nov 06, 2002 2:22 pm 0
Location: South Gloucestershire

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by venusian »

Expense on only part of it. It's also a matter of engagement with the system.

If you need ID to vote then you need to have arranged to get appropriate ID some time in advance, which means you need some conception of when elections are coming around and be interested enough to spend an evening filling in forms, getting stuff counter-signed and so forth. This is far more likely to be true of somebody who is comfortably enabled by the current system than for somebody who's need marginalised by it. Therefore it supports conservatives and suppresses the progressive vote.

(Although there's also an argument to me made that the disadvantaged are compulsory conservatives. If you are barely surviving, you probably can't afford shocks in the systems, therefore you cling grimly to the status quo.)

There's a related effect in the imminent redrawing of constituency boundaries. The country is split into equal-sized blocks according to the number of registered voters, not the number of constituents. Therefore areas with high numbers of dis-engaged citizens are under-represents in parliament.
User avatar
phattslagg
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3578
Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
Location: Worcester, England

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by phattslagg »

Here’s the thing: the tories would never bring in compulsory ID for all citizens, because they’re ideologically opposed to the idea.

But they want it to be compulsory for general elections, specifically. You know - the one chance we get every several years to get rid of them. And they are doing this at a point when they have such a large majority that the chances of flipping them at the next election are already vanishingly small.

The whole discussion around the practicalities of getting ID is a distraction.
User avatar
Rhythm
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6124
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 11:57 am 0
Location: Limbo

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Rhythm »

venusian wrote:Expense on only part of it. It's also a matter of engagement with the system.
And "expense" isn't just measured in £. People who are stretched for money are often stretched for time too (no car, fewer opportunities to go collect a card or request one online). So you're someone who left school with less than ideal grades, you're on a minimum wage role, having to manage a household with next to no cash and even less time. You feel constantly ignored in society... are you really going to spend time and effort finding someone to sign off an ID form for you so you can go claim a voter ID card? We're in a country where healthcare is free but people still don't register with a GP FFS.

I'm an "IT professional" and my GF is ex-marketing, having worked round the world. The last time my GF renewed her passport we had a nightmare finding an approved signee to verify the ID. That list of accepted signatories might be quite wide but you have to have known the person for at least a couple of years. Maybe you're particularly well-connected, Tufty, but we had serious trouble finding someone who could do it.

Again, compulsory ID for citizens is not a bad thing. But what the Tories are doing here is an optional thing. The amount of ID-less people who will exercise their right to collect or claim even a "free" card will be low. Hell, even if it's quite high, anything less than 100% takeup means you're rigging the game.
Steam: SteelyDamn
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by gilesgoat »

.. correct me if I am wrong .. but "the picture of poverty in UK emerging from this discussion" is almost "at levels I never seen/heard of in Italy" ..

Also "I should not even ask" them "what about families/connections/etc. ?" .. in Italy we are kinda used to "have a fuckload of relatives" there's always something going on / someplace you can try to have a look at / go.

To me all this system, compared to the one I was used to in Italy ( and the motivation behind it that are more then legitimate in Italy ) seems really "so strange" I mean heck if you'd be in Naples/surroundings "you can probably buy a fake ID/passport on the black market" but you'd still have one "because you need one" :mrgreen:

The story of "requiring signatures from trusted people" .. is .. "bizarre" to me .. "that's why you go to the Carabinieri station to get passport" it's the Carabinieri that checks you/vouch for you not just "anyone".

As I said "trusted people", I am sure in Naples you can find "any trusted people you want" to sign you anything .. for a price .. because their "services" are NOT free for sure :roll:

Italy is like "a game of papers", if you don't want to play the game don't, but you won't get anywhere, on the other side if you know how to play the game you can really play it .. even if you don't have much money at all.

If you don't want to get engaged in things don't .. but then don't complain when Berlusconi comes at power again or Salvini shouts his weird stuff like "kill all the immigrants" or such ..

Sometime I have the impression some things of UK are still like based "on some medieval principles of lords and trustness and honor and dunno what" .. well we are in 2021 .. things are a bit different now .. "AI does not care for that and can't trust that" :roll:
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
skab
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3448
Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2002 1:53 am 0
Location: Barnyard, Ruhr area, Germany

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by skab »

Greetings from Germany here. Can't understand the opposition against a general personal ID card in the Anglo-Saxon countries, at all. Besides all the official uses and as a proof of age, it's even of great use in all private transactions. Like when you sell a car, you know who the buyer is, so if they tried some insurance fraud, you'd have proof you sold the car and who's the buyer. Need a credit, just show your card. Want to buy something age-restricted, show your card. Want to cast your vote, just show your card. Need a "big" passport for traveling abroad, just order one using your ID card for identification. In theory we could use our card as a smart card for online transactions, but that is hardly used, countries like Finland are way further than good old, inflexible Germany.

All that talk about being free and not wanting to be registered is completely moot. Especially in the age of Google and Facebook and a trackable device in every pocket, but even ignoring all that, if you are in the US, you need to have a social security number and you basically need a drivers licence. So you already got your registration and your ID card.

All this talk about "approved signees" is actually an argument for a proper ID card. You don't need some trustworthy friend if you got an ID from day one.

Introducing an ID card just for voting is indeed a bit fishy, though. Either it's indeed a textbook attempt of voter suppression or a backdoor for a proper ID card, which would be a bit surprising from a Tory government.
User avatar
Rhythm
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6124
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 11:57 am 0
Location: Limbo

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Rhythm »

gilesgoat wrote:.. correct me if I am wrong .. but "the picture of poverty in UK emerging from this discussion" is almost "at levels I never seen/heard of in Italy" ..
Giles, it's insane here. Millions of people having to rely on foodbanks because minimum wage is so low, zero-hour contracts are so standardised, and the benefit net that's supposed to support the ability of companies to pay so little doesn't plug the gap. 31% of kids in the UK are below the poverty line and have to rely on school meals for their only significant sustenance every day (hence why "free school meals during holidays" was such a huge news thing).
Steam: SteelyDamn
User avatar
Rhythm
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6124
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 11:57 am 0
Location: Limbo

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Rhythm »

gilesgoat wrote: As I said "trusted people", I am sure in Naples you can find "any trusted people you want" to sign you anything .. for a price .. because their "services" are NOT free for sure :roll:
Good point. If you want to use your GP to sign your form? Expect to be down £25 or more.
Steam: SteelyDamn
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by gilesgoat »

Rhythm wrote:
gilesgoat wrote:.. correct me if I am wrong .. but "the picture of poverty in UK emerging from this discussion" is almost "at levels I never seen/heard of in Italy" ..
Giles, it's insane here. Millions of people having to rely on foodbanks because minimum wage is so low, zero-hour contracts are so standardised, and the benefit net that's supposed to support the ability of companies to pay so little doesn't plug the gap. 31% of kids in the UK are below the poverty line and have to rely on school meals for their only significant sustenance every day (hence why "free school meals during holidays" was such a huge news thing).
"So WTF are Tories ( or anyone else ) doing ?" .. "Where are those famous 'so good' social services in UK ?" .. we used to say that in Italy "nobody dies of starvation" .. there are associations ( Caritas ) .. things .. volunteers .. stuff .. ovearll also "there's the family" ( heck even Mafia calls itself 'the family' and IS based on some 'family values' ) it's almost impossible to be "totally disconnected" in Italy.

I am starting to suspect "UK looks more to US than anything else in that aspect" in the sense looks to me "there are big social gaps" between "people that have something and people that have nothing".

Is that an effect of "post industrialism ?" or again "excessive capitalism ?" ..

Mah .. seems in a way or another be them Tories or Labour "politicians don't work that well and/or don't do that much" then.
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12524
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by tufty »

phattslagg wrote:The tories are doing this for one reason only: to make it harder for people who are more likely to vote against them to vote.
And, again, that is utter bollocks.

I am personally almost certainly far more left wing than most people here. I'm also now totally disenfranchised, but that's another issue. I've been in the situation where "crushingly poor" would be an apt description, living in rat infested, unheated housing with no hot water and shared bathing / toilet facilities, and having to choose between eating at midday or putting petrol in the bike in order to be able to get to work.

Putting extra hurdles in the way of voting isn't a good thing, but financially speaking the burden is extremely low. It should, of course, be as close to zero as possible, and there are ways to do this even within what has been suggested. Passports and driving licenses are not the only acceptable ID. And as has been pointed out, there's nothing to stop you registering for a postal vote. Overall, it may make people less likely to go and vote, but if you're not interested in taking a step beyond registering to vote, you're probably not interested enough to make an informed vote anyway. I'd argue for a pre-vote exam requiring you to match candidates to policies, to be honest.

And even if the argument that it financially excludes the less well off from voting were true, that doesn't mean that it's excluding those who would vote against the government. You can't rely on the old class based voting tendencies, they are no longer valid. Before the 2019 election, studies were showing the tories having a 17% to 20% lead over Labour in C2DE, and a ~25% lead of "right wing" over "left wing" voters in the same group if we consider the libdems to be left wing. There's far more "left wing" voters in the ABC1 group. The dividing line these days is more to do with age, and the young are more likely to have valid photo ID than the old.

About the only people I see being seriously disenfranchised by this are the homeless, as ID is one of the things that tends to disappear rapidly when you're on the streets. This doesn't mean I don't care about the homeless, of course, they have enough trouble voting already.
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
User avatar
Rhythm
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6124
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 11:57 am 0
Location: Limbo

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Rhythm »

gilesgoat wrote: "So WTF are Tories ( or anyone else ) doing ?"
Rigging the system and taking advantage of a completely ineffectual opposition.
gilesgoat wrote:"Where are those famous 'so good' social services in UK ?"
They were primarily built in a post WW2 environment and have gotten progressively worse ever since, left to languish by subsequent Labour and Conservative governments. Much like a lot of other stuff in Britain, the "good old days" are long, long behind us.
Steam: SteelyDamn
User avatar
Rhythm
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6124
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 11:57 am 0
Location: Limbo

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Rhythm »

tufty wrote:
phattslagg wrote:The tories are doing this for one reason only: to make it harder for people who are more likely to vote against them to vote.
And, again, that is utter bollocks.
I respect your opinions on most things on here but I can't agree with this stance. Asking for ID in a country that doesn't mandate ID cards for all makes voting more difficult, simple as. It's expensive to implement, slows down the voting process and doesn't solve any problems, mainly because of the point you made earlier - voter fraud isn't an actual problem.
One of the key pieces of evidence used to support the need for the Government’s voter ID pilots was discredited by the UK Statistics Authority (UKSA) in the run-up to the 2018 vote. The government claimed that in-person voter fraud more than doubled between 2014 and 2016. While the statistic is technically accurate – a rise from 21 cases in 2014 to 44 in 2016 – the Cabinet Office failed to mention that the number of allegations then fell by more than a third in 2017, to 28.
There are many, many ways to make elections in the UK fairer because god knows they're completely fucked at the moment. That the Tories are pushing this button rather than looking at Proportional Representation or Alternative Vote speaks volumes.
Steam: SteelyDamn
User avatar
phattslagg
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 3578
Joined: Fri May 14, 2004 2:04 pm 0
Location: Worcester, England

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by phattslagg »

tufty wrote:
phattslagg wrote:The tories are doing this for one reason only: to make it harder for people who are more likely to vote against them to vote.
And, again, that is utter bollocks.
Then why are they doing it? The incidence of voter fraud is staggeringly low, and the trial they ran confirmed exactly what the critics are saying:

https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpoli ... elections/
Post Reply