The Dr Who thread

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Harlequin »

KlaxonCow wrote:… You can't do this, as you break the premise of the entire show. That line was crossed. You fucked it, Chibnall. You fucked it all up.
This is a show that has thrived on breaking its own premises for almost my entire life.
KlaxonCow wrote:I mean, for fuck's sake, what's the point of doing "the Cartmel Masterplan" of bringing mystery back to the Doctor... and then employing the ultimate mystery killer. We can hear her thoughts. We, apparently, can hear everyone's thoughts. Go on, let's just jump inside Swarm's mind, find out what he's going to do and not bother with the rest of the show. Heck, if you meet a future incarnation of yourself, Doctor, we can just jump inside their thoughts and now we don't need to bother with the next 4 seasons of Doctor Who.
Because that is what happens with all story presentations that employ voiceover/internal monologue/future description overlaid on past action? I may never watch Memento again.

And the Cartmel[-Aaronovitch-Platt-McCoy] Masterplan, although probably an inspiration, was quite different.
KlaxonCow wrote:… worst episode ever.
Umm... Would you like some capitalisation and extra full stops with that?
merman wrote:I felt it worked well, especially by not explicating stating that
Spoiler: show
Bel was trying to find Vinder, although it was a fairly safe bet that was who she was talking about.
The problem for me was
Spoiler: show
suddenly meeting the “old lady” with so little context. Now it could have added mystery and intrigue, but it felt like it was too much thrown into this one episode. Maybe better to have put more emphasis on the Weeping Angel subplot, and then next chapter worked in the “old lady” to set up the final two parts.
I felt it was an effective experiment, communicating a mess of broken time perhaps better than Moffat's The Wedding Of River Song. The personal timeline flashes fleshed out the companion and semi-companion characters possibly more than entire previous Chibnall seasons. Whether it satisfied people desiring a traditional narrative structure, however, might be a different matter.

I think we may have been given enough of the Doctor's flashes to motivate her to learn more, while next week seems have the Angels as its focus. One nugget I thought may have been lost in the maelstrom was the concept of the three Big Bad monster species[*][/size] continuing to fight for dominance despite there being nothing left to dominate. That idea could perhaps have been worthy of its own story.


[*] Quite when the Sontarans actually became the brilliant irresistible conquering force they believe themselves to be is a mystery we can probably skip.[/size]
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Cloudane »

It was a muddled mess but at least it was entertaining. Which is something most of the Chibnall run has failed to be...

Wondering about old lady now. She was acting very Doctorish.
User avatar
F-ZeroOne
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8211
Joined: Wed Sep 29, 2004 8:27 pm 0

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by F-ZeroOne »

That was pretty good, I think. Interesting to see the Doctor not be in control of things for once. Some nice takes on what the Angels are capable of, though I guess one can argue that the more you see of them the less scary they get.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Harlequin »

F-ZeroOne wrote:That was pretty good, I think. Interesting to see the Doctor not be in control of things for once. Some nice takes on what the Angels are capable of, though I guess one can argue that the more you see of them the less scary they get.
They seemed more effective to me here than in their last couple of Moffat outings.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by KlaxonCow »

Well, this one had a recognisable narrative structure, at least.

Sorry, but I think my problem is that we've had 4 out of the 6 episodes and, so far, episode 1 was just "a trailer" for the rest of the series and didn't really say anything itself, then episode 3 was a muddled narrative mess, which wasn't saying anything more than "time is all fucked up".

I guess we got some narrative on the pregnant lass and the lad who're seeking each other out but otherwise - and this was my real problem with that episode - there was no actual narrative or anything but, like, two bits of information provided in that whole episode to progress the story. It was just a confusing "isn't this all crazy?" mess. But what, ultimately, was the point in that episode?

And maybe my reaction is just knowing what Chibnall is like. In that all those mysteries thrown up in that episode? Well, they've all magically disappeared for this next episode, and I bet they're not really properly addressed ever again.

This is a Chibnall hallmark. To kick lots of "mysteries" into the long grass... and then never actually resolve them at all.

So, my assessment of "worst episode ever" was not just that it was a muddled narrative mess, but it's also because I know what Chibnall is like. He created lots of "mysteries", kicked them into the long grass of future episodes. And those future episodes almost certainly won't address them properly. Indeed, we only have two episodes left here, it's kind of impossible now for all of those threads to be dealt with satisfactorily in the remaining hour and a half we've got left here. I mean, we need to explain the Victorian gentleman, right? So he's going to be at least one episode to come. Then we're at the finale, where it needs to have some resolution - as a story needs to have a beginning, middle and end (though, as Tarantino rightly notes, you don't necessarily have to have those things in that order, but they do need to be there).

Thus, I think the point is that I'm not "blinded by the science (fiction)" in that confused mess of an episode, as I just realise that Chibnall has a habit of "mysteries" with zero resolution, and we've got no time left for him to deal with nearly enough of this with proper resolution. So I'm not impressed by the "mysteries kicked into the long grass" tactic that he likes to use, just because I know, in advance, there won't be a good pay-off for them anyway - so why should I care?

Therefore, I confess that maybe there's a whole big dollop of pre-judgement going on with my "worst episode ever" conclusions there.

But, come on, what's Chibnall ever done, in his Doctor Who writing career, to dissuade me of this? Exactly, absolutely nothing.

And with such little time left in the series - we're two thirds over already - I'm just thinking that there's simply insufficient time left for my criticisms not to prove true. Particularly when we know, for a fact, that "Victorian gentleman" / Liverpool connection has zero explanation so far, so we've got to spend at least one episode dealing with him at some point.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
merman
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10943
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: merman1974
Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
Location: Skegness, England
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by merman »

There was a lot to like in Chapter 4 - Eustacius (Kevin McNally on good form), the “edge” of the village effects and the little epilogue with Vinder. And of course the central figure of Clare, hiding a secret.

The twist was interesting so we shall see where it goes.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
User avatar
Jonesey
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2463
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 3:08 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: J0n3seY
PSN: MrJ0n3s3Y
Location: Gwynedd

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Jonesey »

Bel and Vinder are The Doctor's parents.

Discuss.
"PC Load Letter? What the fuck does that mean?"
*XBL-J0n3seY
*PSN-MrJ0n3s3Y
*SWITCH-SW112256510736
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Harlequin »

Jonesey wrote:Bel and Vinder are The Doctor's parents.

Discuss.
Ooh... I like your mind.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
merman
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 10943
Joined: Wed Feb 16, 2005 1:44 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: merman1974
Yahoo Messenger: andrewrfisher
Location: Skegness, England
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by merman »

Jonesey wrote:Bel and Vinder are The Doctor's parents.

Discuss.
I saw someone else speculating on that.
Could work, may not be the most satisfying way to conclude but it does make sense with The Eternal Child plotline.

Chapter 5 was fun, a real grab bag of ideas. How did the Sontarans know to use the chaos after the Flux to attack Earth? I did love the globetrotting companions in the early 20th Century, it contrasted so well with the spaced out place the Doctor found herself in.

But... the pocket watch. It just feels like a plot device too far.
Spoiler: show
All too easy to imagine it being destroyed/kept out of the Doctor’s reach/grabbed at the last second and drawing out the story.
Twitter, Xbox, Wii U and Steam - merman1974
ZZAP is back - https://www.patreon.com/zzapmagazine
User avatar
F-ZeroOne
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8211
Joined: Wed Sep 29, 2004 8:27 pm 0

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by F-ZeroOne »

I’ve never had a problem with Jodie Whittaker as The Doctor, and I feel this episode finally gave her something to get her teeth into; she was really good in her scenes with “Mother”. It feels a bit like a problem they had with Peter Capaldi, it took them quite a while to settle on how to handle “his” incarnation and just as I think they finally got the hang of it he was gone. It feels the same here.

It was a fun episode - not necessarily one that will stand up to detailed analysis - even if I have some issues with the whole “Division” idea and (assuming it doesn’t turn out to be misdirection) the Doctors role in it.
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by KlaxonCow »

merman wrote:but it does make sense with The Eternal Child plotline.
I don't know that it does.

But, that said, Chibnall's writing is so confusing and inconsistent, that this could well be where it's heading, even though it's quite illogical.

I mean, we were given the exposition, this episode, that the Doctor's from another universe in the multiverse. If that holds then her parents surely can't be of this universe... and, indeed, where would, you know, the regeneration or psychic abilities come from, then?

In the exposition, they touched on how, in different universes, different laws of physics could apply and, therefore, you could explain the Doctor as, like, in that universe, death isn't a thing. The rules are different there (although, this does bring up, in my mind, that if the laws of physics are vastly different in another universe, then surely things from one universe might, in fact, be intrinsically incompatible in another universe - just can't exist there, as they depend on rules that don't exist elsewhere).

But, yeah, I did have similar thoughts. Because, well, they're making a fuss of these lovers meeting up again. So they surely have some kind of narrative significance or what's the point? And then you're thinking, are they significant because of who the baby will eventually be? And then, yeah, you're thinking the Doctor because we now have a "where did she originally come from?" problem.

I noticed a press article about the show making the same point as I did earlier, but now it's even more true.

We have a single episode left. How many threads need to be tied up? It seems impossible, within the allotted time, for us to get a satisfactory conclusion on even half of this shit.

So the criticism of Chibnall holds that, once bitten, I'm twice shy about committing to any "mysteries" he throws out there. Like, don't get too excited by non-linear storytelling and such... it's Chibnall, so it won't ultimately go anywhere or mean anything.

(That article did also touch on something else. That this series might demonstrate that it's really the writing, not her acting, that's Jodie's downfall here. As there's been a bit more "meat" for her to chew in this run of 6 episodes - not much, but a little - and she's done a better job of it. A hint that if Chibnall hadn't fed her crap for most of her run, she could have delivered more. No, not "best Doctor ever" level or anything, but enjoyably competent enough to put that "this is not the Doctor I know" thought out of your head long enough to buy into it. Like, an actor can't do much if all the scripts repeatedly just say "be zany, be clumsy, act serious - rinse and repeat" over and over again.

Then again, Jo Martin knocked it out of the park for the briefest of appearances. I totally want her to be a future Doctor and not a past one, just so we get her back permanently. So it also proves that, yeah, bad casting, sorry.)
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
Little stoned kiwi
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4598
Joined: Mon Oct 27, 2003 6:05 am 0
Location: Christchurch

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Little stoned kiwi »

It could be worse. At least Clara isn't here.
If they think you're crude, go technical; if they think you're technical, go crude. I'm a very technical boy.
User avatar
Ollie
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 4446
Joined: Mon May 03, 2004 7:04 pm 0
Location: London
Contact:

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Ollie »

I think it was presented as an assumption by Tecteun that the timeless child had come through the wormhole from another universe, not as a fact. The Doctor says, "You assumed I came through that wormhole, but you don't know. What if I was waiting there to collected? What if I was supposed to be taken through it? What if whoever left me there was taken by that wormhole?"

If Bel & Vinder are indeed her parents, her regenerative ability will presumably be hand-waved as some consequence of being born under the influence of the Flux, like River Song's was a result of having been conceived in the TARDIS.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by KlaxonCow »

Ollie wrote:If Bel & Vinder are indeed her parents, her regenerative ability will presumably be hand-waved as some consequence of being born under the influence of the Flux, like River Song's was a result of having been conceived in the TARDIS.
Okay...

...but, like, her regenerative ability is the basis for the Timelords. It bought them the eternity they needed to become the masters of spacetime architecture to build TARDISes and going toe-to-toe with the Daleks for the "most technologically advanced race in the universe" prize.

I mean, it's Chibnall. So, yeah, he probably would just hand-wave it away.

Even though, like, it's what the entire premise of the whole show is fundamentally based on (and, indeed, if it's due to the Flux, then that means the whole thing is one gigantic paradox - Tecteun created the Flux, which gives the Doctor her regenerative ability, which she then stole for the Timelords in the past, which allowed them to become masters of life, death, space and time to get to the technologically advanced position of the essentially immortal Tecteun creating the Flux... and around and around we go forever).

And to have something so crucially important to everything just be some hand-wavy paradoxical "accident"?

Well, it's Chibnall. So that's probably exactly what's going to happen. But, for pity's sake, that would be pathetic.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
Cloudane
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7937
Joined: Wed Jun 15, 2005 6:05 pm 0
Location: VRchat

Re: The Dr Who thread

Post by Cloudane »

I really, really preferred when the Doctor was just a humble Timelord like any other who got fed up of life on Gallifrey and decided to go and explore and help people out. Not the centre of the universe, nothing special at all really within the context of their species. It's a good message too, that anyone can be a hero (though obviously Timelords in general have an advantage). Making the Doctor a super special magical centre-of-the-universe totally invincible being really ruins a lot of that for me.

I still have the vain hope that the Master will turn up and say it was all one giant trick "hahaha, did it make you feel good thinking you were SO SPECIAL? How does it feel knowing that I made it all up and you're nothing special after all?" and she says "well thank goodness for that, no I hated it, thank you for clarifying I feel much better now" but of course that will not happen. It'll all be cemented in that she's pretty much the centre of the universe if not multiple universes.

Her coming from a different universe makes too much sense. The thing is, this is something that could work very well if it was the end of the story. If Doctor Who was ending, permanently, in a planned way like "it was always going to be a specific story" like in a video game or a planned series like B5, then it'd be a good time to do an origin story that explains she's from a different universe where things work differently, and was unknowingly the founder of the Timelords etc. But it's not. It's being handed over and is a long running series that may get another hiatus at some point but will probably go on for many more decades.

It's like if you take something like the story of the game Lost Odyssey,
Spoiler: show
eventually you find out why Kain and co seem to be immortal. They're not actually immortal after all, IIRC they just happened to stumble through a portal to where time "flows" at a different pace. A year in their own world takes 1000 years to pass on the other side of the portal. If they're injured, they're patched up at a speed so fast from their body's perspective that is still "connected" to their own world that they don't die. Etc. But you find all this out right at the end, which is when you explain stuff like this and leave you with an emotional impact (they know that once they go home, by the time they've blinked their friends on 'this side' will be long dead) and the whole thing leaves you with an "ohhhh! My goodness." to reflect on as the final credits roll. Not in the middle of the story!
F-ZeroOne wrote:I’ve never had a problem with Jodie Whittaker as The Doctor, and I feel this episode finally gave her something to get her teeth into; she was really good in her scenes with “Mother”. It feels a bit like a problem they had with Peter Capaldi, it took them quite a while to settle on how to handle “his” incarnation and just as I think they finally got the hang of it he was gone. It feels the same here.
Completely agree with this, I only really liked Capaldi's Doctor right towards the end, and the same is happening with Whittaker's. I think she's playing the role quite well now (still a bit breathlessly but not as bad) and quite "Doctor-y", just in time for her to depart.

To an extent "maybe it's us, the audience" - the actors are encouraged to put their own spin on the Doctor and wasn't it the case that JW was told NOT to watch any prior material so she would not be more of the same? After all, the "essence" of a time lord seems to stick around (good egg vs evil bastard etc) but their personality is supposed to be a bit more fluid. But this is uncomfortable for us as viewers. So eventually via viewer feedback etc they end up asked to adjust their performance to something more familiar to us as "Doctor-y" and comfortable.

From what I heard Capaldi was aiming for a callback to Hartnell at first. But much like going back and watching the Hartnell era, you find that he's a much more likeable character when he's played as warm and caring and friends with his companions, and not the kidnapper and general jerk he was in his first few serials. But maybe this comes from starting with newer, warmer Doctors to begin with.
Post Reply