This is a show that has thrived on breaking its own premises for almost my entire life.KlaxonCow wrote:… You can't do this, as you break the premise of the entire show. That line was crossed. You fucked it, Chibnall. You fucked it all up.
Because that is what happens with all story presentations that employ voiceover/internal monologue/future description overlaid on past action? I may never watch Memento again.KlaxonCow wrote:I mean, for fuck's sake, what's the point of doing "the Cartmel Masterplan" of bringing mystery back to the Doctor... and then employing the ultimate mystery killer. We can hear her thoughts. We, apparently, can hear everyone's thoughts. Go on, let's just jump inside Swarm's mind, find out what he's going to do and not bother with the rest of the show. Heck, if you meet a future incarnation of yourself, Doctor, we can just jump inside their thoughts and now we don't need to bother with the next 4 seasons of Doctor Who.
And the Cartmel[-Aaronovitch-Platt-McCoy] Masterplan, although probably an inspiration, was quite different.
Umm... Would you like some capitalisation and extra full stops with that?KlaxonCow wrote:… worst episode ever.
I felt it was an effective experiment, communicating a mess of broken time perhaps better than Moffat's The Wedding Of River Song. The personal timeline flashes fleshed out the companion and semi-companion characters possibly more than entire previous Chibnall seasons. Whether it satisfied people desiring a traditional narrative structure, however, might be a different matter.
I think we may have been given enough of the Doctor's flashes to motivate her to learn more, while next week seems have the Angels as its focus. One nugget I thought may have been lost in the maelstrom was the concept of the three Big Bad monster species[*][/size] continuing to fight for dominance despite there being nothing left to dominate. That idea could perhaps have been worthy of its own story.
[*] Quite when the Sontarans actually became the brilliant irresistible conquering force they believe themselves to be is a mystery we can probably skip.[/size]




