Politics Thread!

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by KlaxonCow »

zip accident wrote:The strange thing is, you don't need to cook.
Well, yeah, I did mention that, as energy costs is one of the roots of the problem here, then cooking - in the sense of "applying heat to food" - is exactly the thing you don't want to be doing as much of right now.

It's also rich coming from the rich. I bet if we did a "rich versus poor cooking challenge" then the rich would fail far worse than the poor, because they eat out at fancy restaurants or get caterers to do it or have "maids" at home that deal with all that food for them. They're too rich to cook, as banks are too big to fail.

But the poor person? No fucking choice in the matter. Cooking - from raw ingredients, preferably - is a money-saving strategy. It's typically cheaper to buy ingredients and make it yourself than to buy some "ready meal" that just needs microwaving.
zip accident wrote:You do need a fridge.
Which requires energy.

Yeah, are folks beginning to realise why, on that "future of energy" thread, I'm advocating for a decentralised renewable future? Where, with solar panels and a battery, you "own the means of (energy) production" and you don't need to pay billionaires for their "approval to be able to exist".

The EU has talked about making it compulsory to install solar panels, batteries, heat pumps and so forth in all new build homes. I hope this pans out, and then - when Europe becomes stupidly rich, from releasing all the money that would otherwise pointlessly go to billionaires who don't need it, and the concept of "energy poverty" is just non-existent, other countries will be pressurised to follow suit.

We can start by cutting off Putin. But it's not as if the Saudi royal family are lovely people either, is it?

I go on about renewables and such, simply because the amount of problems it can solve simultaneously is impressive. Climate change - the usual reason given - is but one reason amongst dozens.

Making electricity abundant, decentralised and "too cheap to meter" - particularly in the Internet / Information Age, where a heck of a lot of what we do is ultimately predicated on energy (and, where it isn't, it can often be made so - e.g. switch from ICE cars to EVs - to take advantage of all the abundant free clean energy that'll be coming) - is technologically possible and would eradicate / eliminate whole swathes of "world problems" that we all have.

I advocate for it because, put simply, this is the first step on a journey towards that post-abundant "Star Trek" money-is-irrelevant future.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by gilesgoat »

One thing to understand, Giles, is that the UK govt doesn't specialise in trying to have its citizens lice with a good support net - instead every side of them is set up to support business.
Business of WHO/WHAT kind of business ? Because let me tell you "from my experience as very small business owner" they certainly seems NOT to support small business like Llamasoft.

Actually "as soon as you earn something as little" they pester you all the time with "pay me this, pay me that".

Zero hour contract I THINK they are not legal in Italy and/or if it's like any contract job it CANNOT be made to last "forever" because after 6 months of "temporay contract employment" or you let me go or the law says you HAVE to employ me full time, in any case you can't go below minimal wage.

There are ways in Italy, up to a point, to circumnavigate all this but they are highly scrutinised and despite all the shit going on ( in Italy ) law is quite good in enforcing certain things so "you don't really mess it up that much" because it's really NOT worth it, if they get you penalities are really severe.

In Italy unfortunately many things vary A LOT region by region .. south Italy .. sadly but "it's a mess by its own" .. north Italy, "varies from east to west" .. council housing I heard it's quite good once/if you manage to get in but waiting lists are long.

Anyway in Italy we are "used to" think that "your primary support net is your own family" .. "the state is the last" living with parents until "really late age" and/or "house passed from mum to dad to you" .. "it's the normal thing" .. "you don't buy a house, if you can, you inherit one" ...

Families, kids, etc.... EH .. "it's years and years" that in many places of Italy, north/more industrialised one especially "natality rate is WELL NEGATIVE" which actually means "local population is disappearing cause nobody does kids any more" .. "typical Italian modern family" is considered ONE kid TWO AT MOST .. lot students "want to build a career/get a good job first" ..

So this means "at very least you have to finish UNI" and then find something "for at least a good 5 years" .. which means "before 30 .. even 40" sometime "you don't have kids" .. IF you are ever going to have them .. it's a complex story ..

Houses in Italy .. eh .. another complex story but "we got many times the point they were building lot of new houses so priced that NOBODY was able/willing to afford them" .. and in the end .. they did NOT sell them to ANYONE !

The idea that "a house will alway increase its value" .. does not quite work like that in Italy, we know that as time passes house gets old and needs fixing .. so over a certain threshold of time you can actually say that value is DECREASING "by natural causes".

Sure there are apartments in Milan costing like/more than London .. and nobody lives in .. they all live on the outskirts of Milan and commute ..

But yeah "as far as I know" and/or "they way been raised up IN THE NORTH", HAS to be said because again "this thing changed from region to region" you think "a lot about money BEFORE to do things" ..

Like ... "you don't have money enough", you don't even think about leaving your parents house and/or buying one (*).

"You don't have a good/decent job" .. "you don't put up a family" ..

"Don't expect anything much from the government and rememeber that the government, all it gives with a hands takes away with another".

About buying (*) .. actually in Italy "everyone that can buys" BECAUSE the cost of rents is sometime even superior than the cost of a mortgage so "unless you really have no choice" there's no point in renting.

Sure banks want some security .. but "normally" .. that would be your parents house ( that by law if you are the child/etc. you ARE entiled to automatically inherit ** ) so there's that even if your job is so and so.

Sure it got a bit more difficult these days .. "but in the end of the day" even the banks found themselves like "hey we may not have any more mortgages that's not good" ..

Then there's a third option about houses that ESPECIALLY in my region, Friuli, is or USED to be "the number one" .. you BUILD one .. which seems "weird" to many people but let me tell you "if you plan all correctly" is MUCH CHEAPER than buying a ready made house ! You'd be surprised as I was .. "the cost it's not in the building" .. but this means "you'll be able to live in in X years, NOT immediately" but if you can do it .. it's probably one of the best/most cost effective options.

Took me 5 years but by that time 1/3 of the mortgage was also already gone.

Anyway even all this "UK business thing" I dare to say "maybe for the BIG business and/or friends of Boris" .. not certainly small business ..

Actually sometime I get the impression they want to shut down all small business.

But yeah "same old story everywhere it seems" .. "you don't have money, you'll never make it, because everything is engineered to be like that" .. "you are rich, you'll get even richer" ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
Rhythm
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6124
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 11:57 am 0
Location: Limbo

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Rhythm »

gilesgoat wrote:
One thing to understand, Giles, is that the UK govt doesn't specialise in trying to have its citizens lice with a good support net - instead every side of them is set up to support business.
Business of WHO/WHAT kind of business ? Because let me tell you "from my experience as very small business owner" they certainly seems NOT to support small business like Llamasoft.
If you wanted to hire a new coder but only wanted to pay minimum wage (because you're a small firm, that's all you can afford) then Universal Credit would step in to cover the difference. Between actual payments, tax credits, other subsidies, that employee would be somewhat shielded. Which in turn shields you, the employer.

And again, if you could pass the appropriate credit check and grab a cheap property to rent out, you'd be entitled to have the gov't pay your mortgage provided you rented to a benefit claimant
Steam: SteelyDamn
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by gilesgoat »

Rhythm wrote:*SNIP*
If you wanted to hire a new coder but only wanted to pay minimum wage (because you're a small firm, that's all you can afford)
NO WE CAN NOT AFFORD EVEN THAT !

Also as an owner of the company the "minimum wage" does not apply ( to me ) .. thankfully ..

So "all you have to do" is to become a landlord and rent the place to someone on benefits and you'll get "money for free guaranteed" form the government ? ..

But then the government "has to pay twice" .. one is the lanlord .. one is the guy on benefits .. if they'd be a council house they would not have the rent to pay at least ?
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by KlaxonCow »

gilesgoat wrote:Business of WHO/WHAT kind of business ?
Their business.

Really, "the party of business" is a facade. It's really "the party of the Old Boys' Network".

You know, when universal suffrage was introduced, folks concentrate - rightly - on the fact that women got the vote, but there were an awful lot of men who also got the vote for the first time too. Because, up until that point, it was land owners only who had the right to vote.

Now, look over at the House of Lords.

Look closely at their full titles: "Lord Archbishop of Canterbury", "Lord Bishop of Birmingham", "Lord Bishop of Worcester" - amongst the Lords Spiritual (automatic peerages for the Church?) - "Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon", "Lord Allen of Kensington", "Baroness Blackwood of North Oxford", etc..

What I'm drawing your attention to is that their full titles are always "of <some land>". Because the Lords were - and still often are - the land owners. The Barons. They had automatic place in government and, until universal suffrage, it was only land owners who had the vote.

Recently, the Prime Minister has been encouraging businesses to go back into the office. But, umm, sorry, that's none of your fucking business, Boris. If a particular business benefits from "hybrid working / work from home" - and their employees enjoy a better work / life balance as a result - then that's between them, and has nothing whatsoever to do with the government.

But, ah, who will suffer if businesses all realise that there's a ton of money to be saved from not paying office rents? If they realise that they can operate just as well - as productivity numbers were the same, or sometimes better, during the forced "work from home" from the pandemic - but save so much money on renting out offices, then that's their business.

It's not their job to support the... landlords. Oh, right. We're back to land and property ownership again, interestingly.

And, as mentioned, the system is designed to support private landlords. Businesses don't have to pay out a decent wage, as the government will cover - from taxpayer money - "housing benefit" which'll be directly paid to the landlords (like, literally, they've made changes to the system that overtly gives direct payment to landlords, so that benefit claimants don't even see the money - it goes straight from the taxpayer to the landlord's pockets. Do not pass go. Do not collect £200).

While we have seen some very overt "jobs for the boys" going on recently. Is there any business case for offering PPE contracts to a business that's never dealt with PPE ever before? Or, for Brexit, a shipping company that owns no ships?

Not remotely. But - oh, look - it's a rich friend. Or a donor to the party. It's a mate of a mate, who wants free taxpayer money.

This is blatant and overt "jobs for the boys" but all of it works like that, really.

So, yeah, what kind of business? Whatever business they are into, or their friends are doing. The business of owning land, where the power has always resided - quite literally, as that was the qualification to be "a Lord" and, though officially that's no longer the case, just take a look at who owns what and realise that it hasn't really changed for centuries upon centuries.

Folks working to pay rent / a mortage? It's modern day feudalism. And towering house prices is the key to them retaining that power.

It's the business of power and retaining power. It's the business of helping your friends retain their power and status. It's about preserving the status quo - the essence of conservativism and what is being "conserved" in the very name "conservative" - so that you being rich and powerful stays exactly the same forever more. Then hand it to your kids and they'll keep it going for centuries more.

I disagree with Marx on the solution. But he was dead right on diagnosing the problem... and we live in an age where "the Robber Barons" who inspired him to invent socialism / communism are on the rise once more.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
Rhythm
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6124
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 11:57 am 0
Location: Limbo

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Rhythm »

gilesgoat wrote:
Rhythm wrote:*SNIP*
If you wanted to hire a new coder but only wanted to pay minimum wage (because you're a small firm, that's all you can afford)
NO WE CAN NOT AFFORD EVEN THAT !
It was a hypothetical, based on a plausible situation. My point being that if you guys ever decided to bring someone else in, at the lowest level you could afford, the gov't would step in to help them out. And that helps you because you get to feel less guilty about not being able to pay the amount you'd actually like to.
gilesgoat wrote: Also as an owner of the company the "minimum wage" does not apply ( to me ) .. thankfully ..

So "all you have to do" is to become a landlord and rent the place to someone on benefits and you'll get "money for free guaranteed" form the government ? ..

But then the government "has to pay twice" .. one is the lanlord .. one is the guy on benefits .. if they'd be a council house they would not have the rent to pay at least ?
Yep, instead of providing a place to live to people who are unable to afford one, they pay benefits to the claimant and rent to the landlord. So the newspaper headlines get to raise ire at the idea that "benefit claimants live in expensive houses" when the real scandal is that landlords are having expensive houses given to them by the government

Claire is likely to never be able to work again. The gov't won't give her a house, as public stock is depleted, but they will pay her money in order that she can find somewhere to rent. So she pays that rent to a landlord who then pays off his mortgage. Via an agent who takes 10%. So he gets a free house, and PurpleBricks earn £140 p/m for doing shag all. It's all tax money, going straight from the exchequer into the hands of private investors. Via a claimant who then gets to feel demonised by ever headline she reads
Steam: SteelyDamn
User avatar
Rhythm
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6124
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 11:57 am 0
Location: Limbo

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Rhythm »

KlaxonCow wrote: And, as mentioned, the system is designed to support private landlords. Businesses don't have to pay out a decent wage, as the government will cover - from taxpayer money - "housing benefit" which'll be directly paid to the landlords (like, literally, they've made changes to the system that overtly gives direct payment to landlords, so that benefit claimants don't even see the money - it goes straight from the taxpayer to the landlord's pockets. Do not pass go. Do not collect £200).
Not with UC. UC pays it to the claimant who then has to pay it straight out again. Housing Benefit went straight to the landlords but UC doesn't.
Steam: SteelyDamn
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by zip accident »

Rhythm wrote:The gov't won't give her a house, as public stock is depleted,
The "right to buy" law that Thatcher brought in is still on the books, so council houses are still rare and effectively can't be built.

It's popular with the few council tenants that are left, because it's essentially free money, but I still don't understand why other governments haven't repealed it.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by KlaxonCow »

Rhythm wrote:Not with UC. UC pays it to the claimant who then has to pay it straight out again. Housing Benefit went straight to the landlords but UC doesn't.
Ah, right. They've changed it.

I guess with the "universality" of universal credit, it kind of has to work that way, as the money is not (at least formally) given for a specific purpose, as the older benefits were.

I mean, in the end, it still ends up in the landlord's pocket. So it's not really an improvement on anything, but at least it's not so blatantly "free money directly to your landlord".

Then again, the fact that it was so blatant made the stupidity of the system all the more obvious for people to baulk at, as the government giving money directly to private landlords - with not even the pretence that it's "your money" anywhere along the line - made the fact that, really, they're just paying off the landlord's mortgage with taxpayer money very plain to see.

Mind you, I'd say that the whole system of money itself is inherently screwed up - the original "Noble Lie" - and this sort of thing just highlights it. I mean, you could see it as the government paying benefits to house people... or you could read it as governments using taxpayer money to pay off private mortgages, on condition they let a poor person "house sit" for them in the meantime.

And the bizarre thing is that both interpretations are arguably equally valid. Depends on how cynically you want to see the world, really.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
gilesgoat
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 27259
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2003 7:54 am 0
Location: Monfalcone, Italy
Contact:

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by gilesgoat »

KlaxonCow wrote:
Rhythm wrote:Not with UC. UC pays it to the claimant who then has to pay it straight out again. Housing Benefit went straight to the landlords but UC doesn't.
Ah, right. They've changed it.

I guess with the "universality" of universal credit, it kind of has to work that way, as the money is not (at least formally) given for a specific purpose, as the older benefits were.

I mean, in the end, it still ends up in the landlord's pocket. So it's not really an improvement on anything, but at least it's not so blatantly "free money directly to your landlord".

Then again, the fact that it was so blatant made the stupidity of the system all the more obvious for people to baulk at, as the government giving money directly to private landlords - with not even the pretence that it's "your money" anywhere along the line - made the fact that, really, they're just paying off the landlord's mortgage with taxpayer money very plain to see.

Mind you, I'd say that the whole system of money itself is inherently screwed up - the original "Noble Lie" - and this sort of thing just highlights it. I mean, you could see it as the government paying benefits to house people... or you could read it as governments using taxpayer money to pay off private mortgages, on condition they let a poor person "house sit" for them in the meantime.

And the bizarre thing is that both interpretations are arguably equally valid. Depends on how cynically you want to see the world, really.
Interesting question/point ..

Let's think ..

"If that person would have money it would pay a rent by itself" ... to a lanlord .. that would rent ..

"That person has no money so they government pays for it" .. to a lanlord ..

So .. "it's still the same thing ?" ..

Does it change if "first go to you, then goes to the lanlord" or "goes directly to the lanlord ?" ..

Now, don't know in UK ( don't even want to know I think prices are INSANE in ANY case * well actually I did see something around here ) .. but in Italy "the cost per month of a mortgage is normally PAR if not even LESS than a rent" .. which mean "it's always best if you can to try to buy", at least "won't go forever and you'll have your own house in the end".

Now if the government would be fair "It should find something like that for those people" .. "instead of putting into an infinite rent scheme at least put them into a scheme that will leave them with a house at some point".

But it seems me you are kind implying that "nobody sells, everyone wants to rent only ?" ..

About the "free money" for the lanlord .. "technically is not free because it gives you in return a house" .. so it's not "for nothing" .. what is actually - in theory - is "much safer money" because the government supposedly pays on time and aways pays .. while you could be skipping rents ...

The thing is "the lanlord will keep that house in rent forever and will never sell" .. because that would be "killing the golden egg goose" also at this point there an "incentive" in "build to rent NOT to sell" ?

If there's really "so many houses for sales" .. would not be better for the government "to open a mortgage and pay for it ?" at least that would be a payment that ends .. OR ... you tell me "there's the thing your benefits/payments could be cancelled at any moment so that's why they don't do it ?" ..
they're just paying off the landlord's mortgage
You mean .. "something of this kind is happening" ???

1. the lanlord buys a house
2. opens a mortgage to pay for it at X payments per months
3. rents the house at 2X per month to somone else
4. the someone else is "someone on benefits" the government pays that 2X rent to the lanlord
5. the lanlord finishes to pay its mortgage, owns the house and has X in the bank as it started

???

I am NOT sure you can do that in Italy, IIRC when I bought a house I think there were clauses about this, I don't think you can rent anything until you have 100% property on it and in Italy that would happen ONLY when you paid your mortgage + all interests IN FULL.

I am not even 100% sure how it works if you can re-sell the house while on mortgage to someone else because technically you DO NOT owe it yet , I know someone else can step in and take the house continuing to finish the mortgage but I think you can do it only if the banks accepts it and I believe before you do that you have to be at least paid in full all the interests of the mortgage.

Hum interesting situation.

[edit] - I had a quick check, actually from 2020 or so, in Italy, you can with some restrictions and you'll loose some tax discounts so yeah I think "technically weird" you could I suppose open a mortgage and "have someone else paying it" .. but I haven't checked 100% the law if it's your FIRST house I THINK "you too have to live in" .. but if the SECOND house you own .. that's totally different but you'll be taxed considerably more ...

Still if you can pull a stunt like that .. you don't even need the money to actually pay for it :?: You'll get it from the government ...
Giles the billy goat
"Baa"
User avatar
PFVA
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 14996
Joined: Fri May 24, 2002 1:40 am 0
Location: Paralel 38

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by PFVA »

gilesgoat wrote:
You mean .. "something of this kind is happening" ???

1. the lanlord buys a house
2. opens a mortgage to pay for it at X payments per months
3. rents the house at 2X per month to somone else
4. the someone else is "someone on benefits" the government pays that 2X rent to the lanlord
5. the lanlord finishes to pay its mortgage, owns the house and has X in the bank as it started

???

I am NOT sure you can do that in Italy,..
That could be done in California. And it was.
Instead of having the old "projects" they changed it so the government would pay the person's rent to a landlord. They said it was to integrate the people receiving welfare with everybody else rather than having the stigma of living in "projects", "ghetos", welfare housing.. I did become a good business to landlords. as the rent was paid by the government. There was limited funds though and when the government payed an x amount of rents it would just place people on a waiting list for housing. That list was based on priorities and the refugees were top of the priority list. You can imagine how much racism and dislike for refugees that brought up. Then there was a time that to make the funds cover more people they started sending them to the interior towns of the valley where rents were cheaper and they ended up with lots of people in those towns who were welfare recipients and again with the stigma of social housing attached they were trying to avoid in first place.

Here we still have social housing in project or ghetto style which causes some social integration problems.Nowadays some better off municipalities like this one have taken to restore old buildings that ended up in the hands of the municipality and no one wanted, dividing them into apartments, and making them social housing specially for young families.
User avatar
zip accident
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 13928
Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
Location: Bristol, UK

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by zip accident »

gilesgoat wrote:Interesting question/point ..

Let's think ..

"If that person would have money it would pay a rent by itself" ... to a lanlord .. that would rent ..

"That person has no money so they government pays for it" .. to a lanlord ..

So .. "it's still the same thing ?" ..

Does it change if "first go to you, then goes to the lanlord" or "goes directly to the lanlord ?" ..
Back in the old days I heard of a tenant who got the housing benefit (3 or 4 months, because the council was slow to sort out paperwork (and housing benefit at that time was the responsiblity of the local council, not the central government)), and skipped out without paying the landlord at all. At that time (long time ago, about that time, not sure if exactly that time) directly paying the landlord was optional.
Now, don't know in UK ( don't even want to know I think prices are INSANE in ANY case * well actually I did see something around here ) .. but in Italy "the cost per month of a mortgage is normally PAR if not even LESS than a rent" .. which mean "it's always best if you can to try to buy", at least "won't go forever and you'll have your own house in the end".
The Tories and to a lesser extent Labour (who idolise "the working class") hate the idea of the unemployed owning housing at the state's expense. Which meant that housing benefit would cover (most of) rent but never mortgages (interesting word mortgage, "dead glove").
Now if the government would be fair "It should find something like that for those people" .. "instead of putting into an infinite rent scheme at least put them into a scheme that will leave them with a house at some point".
Housing here is artificially overpriced and over built. You can buy garden sheds for relative peanuts, but they are legally required to be removable within one day, and never have planning permission for occupation.
But it seems me you are kind implying that "nobody sells, everyone wants to rent only ?" ..

About the "free money" for the lanlord .. "technically is not free because it gives you in return a house" .. so it's not "for nothing" .. what is actually - in theory - is "much safer money" because the government supposedly pays on time and aways pays .. while you could be skipping rents ...

The thing is "the lanlord will keep that house in rent forever and will never sell" .. because that would be "killing the golden egg goose" also at this point there an "incentive" in "build to rent NOT to sell" ?

If there's really "so many houses for sales" .. would not be better for the government "to open a mortgage and pay for it ?" at least that would be a payment that ends .. OR ... you tell me "there's the thing your benefits/payments could be cancelled at any moment so that's why they don't do it ?" ..
they're just paying off the landlord's mortgage
You mean .. "something of this kind is happening" ???

1. the lanlord buys a house
2. opens a mortgage to pay for it at X payments per months
3. rents the house at 2X per month to somone else
4. the someone else is "someone on benefits" the government pays that 2X rent to the lanlord
5. the lanlord finishes to pay its mortgage, owns the house and has X in the bank as it started

???

I am NOT sure you can do that in Italy, IIRC when I bought a house I think there were clauses about this, I don't think you can rent anything until you have 100% property on it and in Italy that would happen ONLY when you paid your mortgage + all interests IN FULL.
No such clause here, tenants paying off a landlords mortgage is a thing and has been for a long time.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
User avatar
Harlequin
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 6505
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2002 4:19 am 0
Location: London, directly above the centre of the Earth.

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by Harlequin »

zip accident wrote:(interesting word mortgage, "dead glove").
More 'dead pledge/reward', it seems, apparently referring to the ending of the deal.
Emoticon and contraction free since... quite a while ago.
User avatar
tufty
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 12524
Joined: Fri Jan 07, 2005 4:52 pm 0
Location: French Alps

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by tufty »

It comes from (old) french, like a lot of things in English. "gage" in current French is a reference to a pledge or a pawning of something, you might be required to provide a "certificat de non gage" when selling a used vehicle, for example, certifying there's no outstanding debt attached to it. "gage" is also the base for "wage".
"massive retard™", "full of shit™", "tiny bitch™", "retarted™", "a bit of a one trick pony™", "petty™", "simple minded idealistic twat™", "miserable humourless fucker™"
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8447
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Re: Politics Thread!

Post by KlaxonCow »

I like to read it as "death's grip", because that sounds cool.

But where "gage" is literally grip / hand / glove, but semantically means "pledge / debt / wage (/ bet or wager, archaically)" and it's a poetic reading.

To be in someone's debt is like to be within someone's grip / hand / glove. They have a hold of you. Gripping your arm, so you can't run away.

That's the poetry behind it. That to be in someone's debt is to be, poetically, in their hand or grip (or "glove", if you like).

If I make a pledge to you, then I am - poetically speaking - placing myself in your hands. If I earn a wage, then I am - poetically speaking - putting myself in my boss's hands. That he has a figurative "grip" on me (and a literal one, in the sense that, to earn my wage, I must turn up to work when I'm required, I must do the jobs that I'm assigned, and so forth - so I am "in the grip" of my work there, if I expect to be paid).

You get the gist. It's idiomatic. Literally "hand / grip" but means "to be indebted" to someone (as a pledge is a promise of fulfilling a debt in the future, as a wage is the payment of the debt your boss owes you for the work you do, etc.).

As I covered before, money itself is just symbolic debt.

I do a job of work for my boss, so he's in my debt for the favours (work) I've done for him - which he pays off with wages at the end of the month.

And, as I say, if you look at a Bank of England note, it actually literally says "I promise to pay the bearer on demand the sum of...", the value of the note and then the signature of the Chief Cashier of the Bank of England.

Bank notes are also called "promissory notes" - because they have that promise to pay on them - and "promissory note" is synonymous with - or just the fancy way of saying - "I.O.U.". UK bank notes are quite literally I.O.U.s from the Chief Cashier of the Bank of England.

Modern notes have all manner of colours and holograms and shit on them - anti-forgery devices - but the essence of the note remains that promise at the top. You can see this more clearly on an old "white fiver":

Image

Like, it's got the Bank of England logo and name, and it's all written in fancy handwriting (though, legally speaking, these are just decoration and mean nothing) but, besides the decoration, it's literally just that "I promise to pay the bearer on demand the sum of..." text and the signature.

And, you know, I took a scrap of paper and wrote "I.O.U. £5" and signed it, that's also a "promissory note" too (and, with the signature, it's also a contract - and contract law applies - which is legally enforceable).

Money is debt. Or, more precisely, it's the symbolic token system that we use to measure our interpersonal debt with each other.

And the useful thing about debt is that it's a transferable concept.

E.g. I loan £10 from Yak. Giles asks me for £10. So I give Yak's £10 note to Giles.

Now, I could insist on Giles personally paying me the £10, and then I take that £10 note and give it to Yak. But debt is transferable, so I can also simply say "look, giles, just give Yak £10" and cut myself out as the middle man.

This is fine, as the outcome ends up the same. Yak has his £10 note back, I'm no longer in Yak's debt and Giles is no longer in my debt. Exact same outcome as if we played it out and Giles gave me the £10 note - cancelling out his debt to me - and then I paid it to Yak - cancelling out my debt to him, and giving Yak back his £10 note.

It's this transferability of debt that allows money to work.

Because, of course, as we've noted, it says on the note itself that it's the Bank of England (well, the current Chief Cashier thereof - corporations, as abstract entities, do not have signatures and contract law demands a signature to legally put someone on the hook - so the Chief Cashier takes on all the bank's debts - yes, personally - but they'll be a clause in their employment contract that says "all such debts will be taken on by the Bank of England", so it's the bank that pays but it legally has to operate through a person, as a signature is needed) that owes Yak - the bearer of the note - the debt.

So, legally speaking, the Chief Cashier owes all of us all the bank notes we have. But because debt is transferable, then my boss can pay me a few of the "I.O.U. £20" notes to me as wages, then I can take those promises of debt and give them to the shop keeper, who'll trade them for items at his shop.

Yes, if you think of it more literally like this, then it's all a bit mad. But the beauty of debt is that it's transferable, so we don't have to think of the grand scheme of things at all. You only have to concentrate on what debts you owe other people and what debts are owed you. Beyond that, it doesn't matter. Because debt is transferable. So it doesn't matter if it's me or Giles who hands that £10 note back to Yak, as long as he eventually gets what he's owed, who cares where it comes from exactly?

And that's really what money is. A token system for keeping track of debts.

I'm owed for doing work for my boss. He hands me some "I.O.U." notes (well, not really, it's paid into my bank electronically through PAYE and all that - but, for the example, imagine he's literally counting out notes into my hand). I want a fish supper to eat tonight, so I go to the shop and grab one. Then I trade some of those "I.O.U." notes for the item - and the shop keeper is happy for me to leave with it, as my debt to him (that is, letting me leave the shop with the item and granting it as being "my property" now) is paid by letting him have some of those "I.O.U." notes.

The shop keeper is happy with this arrangement, because everyone accepts these "I.O.U." notes - it's legal tender, pal! - so he can, in turn, trade those "I.O.U." notes for more stock to fill his shelves from his supplier. And the supplier's happy to take them, as they can be handed out to their employees as wages. And employees are happy to take them because you can, indeed, trade them for actual useful things in shops.

And so on and so forth - around and around it goes. The mad thing being that this same £20 note can represent all kinds of different debts, as it goes around the big circle of trade. But debt is transferable, so it doesn't actually matter.

What matters is that, at the end of the day, through this "debt token system", we all conducting "fair exchanges" and everyone who's owed is eventually paid.

The mad thing is that, well, what exactly is it that the Bank of England is promising us?

Before we abandoned the Gold Standard, the promise was quite literal. You could wander over to the Bank of England and "demand", as the note words it, that they pay their debts to you immediately. And they'd weigh out five pounds (in weight) of sterling silver.

There you go. Debt paid.

You now have the five pounds (in weight of) Sterling (silver). Yup, that's why the currency is called "the pound" (and on international money markets, "pound sterling") because it used to quite literally represent one pound in weight of sterling silver. And, yeah, it was tied to silver, not gold - though, you know, maybe the bank would actually pay you the equivalent in gold, rather than silver, if their silver stocks were a bit low. Again, doesn't matter, as long as it's deemed equivalent, then the debt is paid.

These days, though, if you go to the Bank of England and "demand" your debt is paid, then they'll take your five pound note... and hand you five £1 coins (I've never tried it, but I'm reliably informed that this is quite literally what happens - they won't refuse your debt, as they legally have to honour it, but it's just trading one set of tokens for another set of tokens, so it's pointless to bother them with your "demands"). Or, of course, the equivalent thereof - so two £2 coins and a £1 coin will do, or ten 50p coins. Whatever. Depends what they've got most of and want to get rid of, really.

There are some folks - conspiracy theorists, mainly - who demand that we should go back to the Gold Standard, and you really get given gold and silver.

But, ah, they miss the point. Gold and silver really has no intrinsic value either (well, gold is an excellent conductor and silver has anti-bacterial properties - but, like, no-one is "demanding" their gold and silver for those reasons, are they?). It was just the old-school "universal standard" token system.

So, no, I have no problem that they traded one set of "tokens" for another set of "tokens". Makes no difference. Indeed, it just helps highlight how the whole thing is perfectly abstract and symbolic anyway - and, cue the meme, "always has been".

We are, in fact, just trading promises and favours, really. The tokens are there to keep track of it, to ensure "fair exchange" (which is, of course, "no robbery", as the saying reminds us).

Money is debt. Or, well, the token system for keeping track of it anyway.

Bill Gates is a multi-billionaire for the "debt" we owe him for giving us all copies of Windows on our PCs. Yeah, I know. A somewhat imposed debt, as the fucking thing comes with it pre-installed, like it or not. But, nonetheless, that's why he's rich. We all owe him for that "favour" of supplying software to us.

The debt that the world collectively owes Jeff Bezos, to make him filthy rich, is the Amazon website. Go on, admit it, you've bought stuff from there and had it delivered. It was not diplomatic to say so, but he wasn't wrong that we've all paid for him to go joyriding in space. Or we've paid off our debts to him for those products and home delivery, and he chooses to spunk it up the wall with his penis-shaped space rockets. It's a free world, unfortunately. He has every right.

So, now seeing the world from this perspective, a pledge is a promise of debt. It's effectively money - just not yet paid off.

And this is quite literally how banks operate. When you take out a mortgage contract, you've got a piece of paper that essentially "I.O.U. <mortgage amount>" and you signed it. The mortgage contract is also money. Not "like" money, or "equivalent to" money. It is quite literally money.

That's what happened in the 2008 Banking Crisis. They were giving out "sub-prime mortgages" - which just means handing out mortgages to people who have no chance of ever paying it off - and because mortgages are money, they were bundling these up into "packages" and then selling those.

Then it became clear to the world that these "sub-prime mortgages" were useless. They were never actually going to be paid, therefore the money they represented does not, in fact, exist. The promise on the notes, if you like, was not good. The promise of debt would never be honoured, in reality.

So billions of dollars of debt - which has, as money does, gone all around the world, circling around, being spent here, there and everywhere (so it's now simply impossible to recall it all, as people have spent the money that the mortgage contracts represented already) - just vanished. The world economy was, suddenly, billions of dollars poorer.

And, in the big picture, what this means is that there's not enough money in the entire "token system" to honour everyone's debts. If everyone asked for it back, then we'd run out of tokens, before everyone is paid.

That's why there were runs on the bank. Because, like, whoever's last to ask for their money back would be the one who's told "sorry, no more money left". And - like folks buying toilet rolls in a pandemic - the fear of being that last person who just loses all their cash means that everyone rushes to get their money out, corporations all start demanding that their outstanding debts are paid right now. Because whoever's last will find there isn't enough money left in the system to honour it all, and they just lose out.

The funny thing is that there really is a "the only thing to fear is fear itself" to this. If folks didn't run on the banks and companies didn't demand their debts back - all at the same time - then the fact that there's not enough "tokens" in the system to honour everyone's debt could be ignored. I mean, the system's already full of bogus money anyway. Forged notes, criminal activities, theft, etc.. It seems deeply unlikely that, even without a banking crisis, if we really did call in all debts, that the amount of "tokens" would actually match up to the amount of debt that needs to be paid.

One valid reaction to the sub-prime mortgages could have been to just ignore it. Carry on as normal. The fact that the amount of "tokens" doesn't actually match the amount of debt could be ignored. Because, in all probability, the tallies have never actually matched up in reality at any point.

But the problem is - as with people going crazy buying bog roll in a pandemic - you don't want to be the last one. The person who's not freaking out and buying it all, as you'll be the one meeting empty shelves. It doesn't matter that toilet roll is almost always manufactured locally (because it's a bulky product with only pennies profit on each roll, so importing it doesn't make much economic sense) - the fear is fear itself. There's actually enough toilet roll to wipe everyone's arses, but not if, like, people are freaking out and buying 50 packets each. Then we meet empty shelves - even though, overall, there's more than enough - because the locusts have descended and taken them all in a panic.

So, a rational response to "sub-prime mortgages" or toilet roll panics is to, like, do absolutely nothing. And if everyone did that then, amusingly enough, nothing untoward would likely happen. But once someone starts "panic buying" or making a run on their bank account, then everyone else joins the mass-hysteria, until it actually becomes a genuine problem... and then you've got to join in, or you will be the one who ends up with nothing.

But, yeah, people might imagine that when you take out a mortgage contract, the bank reaches into its savings and loans you the money from its savings. Nope, the mortgage contract itself is the money. Or represents it. And, thus, they can sell it and so forth.

In signing the mortgage contract, you are, in fact, creating the money that you're loaning from the bank. As weird as that sounds.

Which brings us to the final piece of the puzzle: Inflation.

Right now, everything's getting more expensive. But, hmm, over time, things just naturally keep getting more expensive. Like, back in the '80s / '90s, you could get a 20 pack of cigarettes and matches, and still get change for £2 (I used to smoke back then, but not anymore).

What's going on is that the amount of "tokens" being created - folks signing mortgage contracts and creating "new money" from nothing - is outstripping the amount of things out there in the world that it's supposed to represent. The money supply is inflating. But what the money supply represents - all the things, all the materials, all the labour, etc. and all the things that money can buy - has not inflated to the same extent.

And, well, if "money supply = all the things it represents" and you're making the "money supply" side of the equation bigger, while the "all the things it can represent" hasn't appreciably risen, then this means that one unit of "money" now represents less things. Or, if you prefer, one thing now costs more money tokens to acquire.

This didn't used to happen under the Gold Standard. You can look up the graphs, and there was literally no inflation of any kind for centuries upon centuries. Then the Gold Standard was abandoned and inflation started happening.

Because when money had to be pegged to gold and silver, then there's only so much gold and silver in the world. It limited "money creation". It couldn't just be invented from nowhere. So the "money supply = all the things it can represent" equation always stayed more or less balanced.

But once the Gold Standard was gone and your five pound note was now equivalent to five one pound coins, and not five pounds of Sterling Silver, this lifted the lid on banks and governments and corporation creating "money from nothing".

And this has just been getting worse and worse and worse, as the decades pass.

But, luckily, as it's all just symbolic, a solution to this problem is that when it all gets so bad that a loaf of bread is worth £100, you can just declare that all prices have two zeroes struck from the end - so £100 becomes £1 - and then carry on as before (until it gets inevitably worse and worse, and we have to re-adjust it again).

But the fact that inflation just steadily gets worse and worse over time just means that people are getting greedy, inventing new "money from nothing" all the time, and are de-valuing the currency itself.

(Yes, having more and more millionaires, simply means that a million pounds is worth less. All the greed out there is falling foul of "the Alchemist's Paradox" but no-one really seems to understand that.)

We've got this "cost of living" inflation right now because, with our "money supply = all the things it can represent", the equation can work both ways. In this case, "all the things it can represent" has just gotten suddenly smaller - as it now doesn't legally include Russian oil and gas - so the ratio has changed and, again, there's too many "tokens" to represent "all the things", so a single unit of "money" doesn't buy you as many things as it used to.

This is why, in the NFT and crypto thread, I tried to point that out that as mad and stupid as NFTs are - and they are - the real money system honestly doesn't make that much more sense. It's just that, like, we've had it all our lives, so we're used to it and its peculiarities.

But, yeah, in this view, one can see that "pledge / debt / wage / wager" and so forth are essentially equivalent from a "promise to pay a debt" perspective. And, poetically speaking, we can see this as idiomatically "being in someone's grip". That we are idiomatically "in their hands".

So, like, you can go with the literal translation of something like "death's grip" - which sounds cool - but, semantically, the "death pledge" just means that the pledge is good... until you're dead. That it's a life-long pledge. Has no time limitation.

And, as mentioned, is really just speaking to how the pledge ends. Either you pay it off... or you die, before you've paid it off (and, either way, the "death pledge" is ended).

But I like the poetic "death's grip" because, come on, in practice, that captures exactly how it feels perfectly, right?
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
Post Reply