Paranormal season
Re: Paranormal season
I'm reminded of the pigeons experiment.
Researchers took some pigeons and then hooked up a food dispenser to a button. Press the button and food is dispensed.
It didn't take the pigeons long to work out how this worked.
But they played with the formula to see how the pigeons reacted. So, now, for the second version of the experiment, the pigeons have to hit the button twice - to "double click" - and the food is dispensed.
Takes a little longer to nail this new slightly more complex pattern, but they get it.
And they kept playing with the formula. Now you have to hit the button, wait 5 seconds, then hit the button again.
Of course, the more complicated the pattern, the longer it takes to fathom out how it works. But the pigeons usually mostly got it eventually.
But then they did something radical and different. The new pattern was "random". There is, in fact, no connection between the button and the food dispenser at all, this time. It'll just randomly dispense food. Picks a random number of seconds and that's when the food will drop. The button is not even involved anymore.
But the pigeons, trained to discover the patterns to get the food, kept doing that. They tried all different combinations.
And, basically, things went a bit mad.
Like, one pigeon might have pressed the button, spun around 3 times, then double tapped the button, then spun one more time in the other direction and pressed the button. Another pigeon might be found pressing the button, pacing to the back of the cage and then back to the button, to strike it again.
They came back and all the pigeons were performing some kind of random "ritual" over and over.
Because the pigeons were trying to work out what the new pattern was. And as they did whatever they were doing, food was dispensed. So, oh, that must be the new pattern. Whatever I was just doing, try doing it again.
Oh, I've redone the pattern and it doesn't seem to be working. It must be because I got the pattern slightly wrong. Okay, time to try it again with some variations.
And, you know, by random chance, the food might dispense again, in the middle of them trying to fathom out the pattern. This reinforces them to think that they must be onto something, and double down trying to nail what the pattern must be.
This continues until all the pigeons are found performing their own little "superstitious" rituals to encourage the food to dispense.
I find this experiment enlightening, because the point is that the pigeons are not, in fact, being at all irrational. But yet they've ended up performing silly rituals. They've become "superstitious pigeons", you might say.
And the fundamental problem that brings about this behaviour is intrinsic. The problem is that how do you tell the difference between "no pattern" - it's random - and that there is, in fact, a pattern but you just performed it slightly wrong?
It's not irrational. It's not a flaw in how brains work. It's not that, as far as we know, pigeons are particularly vulnerable to superstition.
It's an intrinsic logical problem. From the outside, there's just no way to tell the difference between "random" and "no, there really is a pattern, but it's complex and you're just getting the ritual slightly wrong".
If you're just watching the food dispenser's behaviour, there just is no easy intrinsic way to tell the difference.
The chief insight there is that it's intrinsic. It doesn't matter how smart or dumb you are, every rational agent is vulnerable to this "logical problem" in identifying patterns.
Indeed, there's even the argument that smarter people could prove more vulnerable to this, as their brains are really good at rationalising stuff and pulling out ever more complex patterns to explain it all. That when a smart person falls for ideas like ghosts or gods or healing crystals, their intelligence can even work against them, as they'll be really good at reasoning out some nonsense to try to make sense of it all. Like, they'll pull in quantum physics or rationalise that the lack of evidence of a god is proof of that god deliberately trying to hide themselves from us (there's a logical fallacy in there, of course, but being smarter doesn't help, as you can layer up the cognitive defences of this belief nice and high, that it can't be so easily penetrated with common sense to make you catch your own dissonance).
There's also the philosophical idea that if Roy Walker is still alive, then that's what happened. Even if I really was recalling an alternate timeline then one could logically argue that it doesn't matter - I'm not in the alternate timeline anymore, clearly, so what happened there doesn't apply here anymore anyway.
So, you know, even if it were true - I'm sure it isn't true - then there's the argument that it's irrelevant anyway. If time really can move around like that, then time has always moved around like this. And that's how time has always been.
My realisation that this is how time works did not cause time to work that way. It always worked that way, and I'm just realising it. My realisation of how reality works is not affecting how reality works - that would be "magical thinking" to believe it's the case.
So, you know, regardless of whether I believe there's a god or not, there either is a god or there isn't. My belief doesn't alter that fact. Indeed, if my level of conviction did actually alter reality that way, then I would be responsible for creating God by just firmly believing in him (or vice versa, being convinced God doesn't exist made him go "poof!" out of existence).
This is not how reality works. If it did work that way, this would imply that I have god-like powers myself - indeed, extra-god-like powers, as I apparently can make gods appear and disappear by my belief.
It's not true. It doesn't make sense for it to be true. The level of my belief in something does not cause it to become true or false. It either was true or it was false all along... and all that's changing is my mind. Realisation of how reality works is only according my thinking with what's out there, it's not changing anything but me.
I like the pigeons experiment. It shows you that this isn't really a question of levels of belief, or "being dumb", or anything. It's an intrinsic logical problem, and therefore all of us must remain vigilant - being clever is no defence (it might even potentially make things worse, even).
Basically, "don't get cocky, kid" and always double-check your workings out. Just in case.
Indeed, the more convinced you are that you're right, the more you should worry that you're probably fooling yourself and redo your thinking, one more time, just to be absolutely sure.
Researchers took some pigeons and then hooked up a food dispenser to a button. Press the button and food is dispensed.
It didn't take the pigeons long to work out how this worked.
But they played with the formula to see how the pigeons reacted. So, now, for the second version of the experiment, the pigeons have to hit the button twice - to "double click" - and the food is dispensed.
Takes a little longer to nail this new slightly more complex pattern, but they get it.
And they kept playing with the formula. Now you have to hit the button, wait 5 seconds, then hit the button again.
Of course, the more complicated the pattern, the longer it takes to fathom out how it works. But the pigeons usually mostly got it eventually.
But then they did something radical and different. The new pattern was "random". There is, in fact, no connection between the button and the food dispenser at all, this time. It'll just randomly dispense food. Picks a random number of seconds and that's when the food will drop. The button is not even involved anymore.
But the pigeons, trained to discover the patterns to get the food, kept doing that. They tried all different combinations.
And, basically, things went a bit mad.
Like, one pigeon might have pressed the button, spun around 3 times, then double tapped the button, then spun one more time in the other direction and pressed the button. Another pigeon might be found pressing the button, pacing to the back of the cage and then back to the button, to strike it again.
They came back and all the pigeons were performing some kind of random "ritual" over and over.
Because the pigeons were trying to work out what the new pattern was. And as they did whatever they were doing, food was dispensed. So, oh, that must be the new pattern. Whatever I was just doing, try doing it again.
Oh, I've redone the pattern and it doesn't seem to be working. It must be because I got the pattern slightly wrong. Okay, time to try it again with some variations.
And, you know, by random chance, the food might dispense again, in the middle of them trying to fathom out the pattern. This reinforces them to think that they must be onto something, and double down trying to nail what the pattern must be.
This continues until all the pigeons are found performing their own little "superstitious" rituals to encourage the food to dispense.
I find this experiment enlightening, because the point is that the pigeons are not, in fact, being at all irrational. But yet they've ended up performing silly rituals. They've become "superstitious pigeons", you might say.
And the fundamental problem that brings about this behaviour is intrinsic. The problem is that how do you tell the difference between "no pattern" - it's random - and that there is, in fact, a pattern but you just performed it slightly wrong?
It's not irrational. It's not a flaw in how brains work. It's not that, as far as we know, pigeons are particularly vulnerable to superstition.
It's an intrinsic logical problem. From the outside, there's just no way to tell the difference between "random" and "no, there really is a pattern, but it's complex and you're just getting the ritual slightly wrong".
If you're just watching the food dispenser's behaviour, there just is no easy intrinsic way to tell the difference.
The chief insight there is that it's intrinsic. It doesn't matter how smart or dumb you are, every rational agent is vulnerable to this "logical problem" in identifying patterns.
Indeed, there's even the argument that smarter people could prove more vulnerable to this, as their brains are really good at rationalising stuff and pulling out ever more complex patterns to explain it all. That when a smart person falls for ideas like ghosts or gods or healing crystals, their intelligence can even work against them, as they'll be really good at reasoning out some nonsense to try to make sense of it all. Like, they'll pull in quantum physics or rationalise that the lack of evidence of a god is proof of that god deliberately trying to hide themselves from us (there's a logical fallacy in there, of course, but being smarter doesn't help, as you can layer up the cognitive defences of this belief nice and high, that it can't be so easily penetrated with common sense to make you catch your own dissonance).
There's also the philosophical idea that if Roy Walker is still alive, then that's what happened. Even if I really was recalling an alternate timeline then one could logically argue that it doesn't matter - I'm not in the alternate timeline anymore, clearly, so what happened there doesn't apply here anymore anyway.
So, you know, even if it were true - I'm sure it isn't true - then there's the argument that it's irrelevant anyway. If time really can move around like that, then time has always moved around like this. And that's how time has always been.
My realisation that this is how time works did not cause time to work that way. It always worked that way, and I'm just realising it. My realisation of how reality works is not affecting how reality works - that would be "magical thinking" to believe it's the case.
So, you know, regardless of whether I believe there's a god or not, there either is a god or there isn't. My belief doesn't alter that fact. Indeed, if my level of conviction did actually alter reality that way, then I would be responsible for creating God by just firmly believing in him (or vice versa, being convinced God doesn't exist made him go "poof!" out of existence).
This is not how reality works. If it did work that way, this would imply that I have god-like powers myself - indeed, extra-god-like powers, as I apparently can make gods appear and disappear by my belief.
It's not true. It doesn't make sense for it to be true. The level of my belief in something does not cause it to become true or false. It either was true or it was false all along... and all that's changing is my mind. Realisation of how reality works is only according my thinking with what's out there, it's not changing anything but me.
I like the pigeons experiment. It shows you that this isn't really a question of levels of belief, or "being dumb", or anything. It's an intrinsic logical problem, and therefore all of us must remain vigilant - being clever is no defence (it might even potentially make things worse, even).
Basically, "don't get cocky, kid" and always double-check your workings out. Just in case.
Indeed, the more convinced you are that you're right, the more you should worry that you're probably fooling yourself and redo your thinking, one more time, just to be absolutely sure.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- Deckard
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 10749
- Joined: Fri Jun 18, 2004 11:27 pm 0
- Location: Falmouth, Cornwall, UK
Re: Paranormal season
We really are just pattern recognition devices and guesswork.
Now with a new Mac Mini Pro so dont judge me !
- RedOktober
- Baaaaaa!

- Posts: 4788
- Joined: Sun Sep 04, 2005 11:15 pm 0
- Location: Stalin's Organ
- Contact:
Re: Paranormal season
Is there a special shop where you can still buy phones with cameras built in the mid to late 2000's?
I assume they are for ufo, bigfoot and lake monster hunting.
If you can see something clearly, it's just boring and not a mystery.
I assume they are for ufo, bigfoot and lake monster hunting.
If you can see something clearly, it's just boring and not a mystery.
Sponsoring terrorism at £1 per mile.
Re: Paranormal season
I have visited WW2 BUNKERS REALLy bad feeling around there some places up to a thousand people died there
Holier than thou
Re: Paranormal season
AIs don't "hallucinate" at all though - that's just more marketing lies (same as calling LLMs "AI" in the first place) straight from the techbros to ascribe human experience to randomised output from a stochastic parrot that has zero knowledge of what it is actually doing.Dvorak wrote: But seeing AIs hallucinate I'd say confabulation is a basic process within any mind, bridging stepping stones of what we actually know.
Re: Paranormal season
The term "AI" carries too much baggage, because we make a whole bunch of assumptions when we hear the word "intelligent".
It's more correct to say that LLMs are "artificial cognition". They are a (crude, known to be incomplete) simulation of what natural neural networks do.
"Intelligent" makes assumptions about what that cognition is doing and what its end results are going to be, which are, indeed, overstepping the mark. But "cognition" only says that the artificial brain is doing stuff. That it is functioning. No assumption that that cognition has any intelligence to it, knows what it's doing or will even produce useful results.
It's worth noting that a parrot is a living being and, therefore, exhibits "cognition", even if we're denying its mimickery the label of being "intelligent" behaviour.
One must be careful not to go too far in either direction. Are LLMs over-hyped? Yes. But, equally, under-hyping is also incorrect - these "stochastic parrots" are picking up context and nuance in their coherent responses.
The comparison to the natural world - which has all sorts of neural networks, at different levels of cognition - is probably right. Are LLMs as cognitively clever as humans? Nope, not at all. But are they at the cognitive level of, say, a dog? Or a cat? Or a mouse? Or an ant?
Like, in the natural world, we see a whole spectrum of different levels of cognition from the genuinely non-existent - the "knee-jerk reaction" - all the way to us self-aware apes discussing the philosophical implications of it all.
But there's plenty of stepping stones in-between. Like, a dog does recognise the meaning of the odd word or two. Chimps do recognise themselves in a mirror, but plenty of other animals don't and will start threatening the "other animal" they see in the looking glass. Some animals can follow a ball under a cup and have awareness of an object that they can't see, but other absolutely can't (object permanence).
Dogs and cats dream. I have no idea if ants do, though.
You hopefully get the gist. It is not some simple binary of "an inanimate object" or "as clever as a human being". There are levels and degrees of cognition. Certain "milestones" - theory of mind, object permanence, symbolic reasoning, etc. - that different animals can and can't manage.
Where is current "artificial cognition" on this spectrum? Unfortunately, it's really, really hard to tell, as LLMs are special-purpose - dedicated to language - where our animal cousins, out in the wild, need to be much more general purpose to survive. So LLMs do exhibit some really quite freaky "intelligent" responses sometimes - and they are speaking coherent English, which is more than a mouse can do.
But this is not apples-to-apples, so you can't directly compare. A mouse needs to do much more than just process language tokens and nothing else. It cannot dedicate the whole of its neural network to that one task, at the expense of, you know, eating, breathing, working out where its next meal is coming from, avoiding predators, etc..
So this makes it real hard to say where on the amoebas-to-humans cognition spectrum they are. And I won't dispute the "stochastic parrot".
But I will defend that neural networks are genuinely AI. It is "cognition" that they are simulating - and, from the results so far, we can see that the simulation does actually work, as the sentences are most often coherent and even correct. And it is picking up context and nuance from the input. Even if, yes, I'm eternally annoyed, in my conversations with these LLMs, that they keep parroting the party line and won't think for themselves sufficiently for my tastes. With encouragement, you can get it to agree to novel concepts and make progress. But, ah, then it falls back to whatever fucking Wikipedia says 5 seconds later.
It shouldn't be over-hyped, but it also shouldn't under-hyped. This is cognition (of the artificial simulated sort) and they are somewhere on the "ladder". But who knows exactly where? It's not apples-for-apples comparing a dedicated language network to a natural all-purpose network that has a thousand other duties it must take care of as well. Is ChatGPT two versions away from being SkyNet, or is it only as smart as an otter but its dedicated purpose can easily fool us into thinking it's higher up on the cognition ladder than it is?
The real underlying problem - the philosophical bit we should actually be worried about, and what the AI experts are warning of - is that, looking at nature, it really does seem to just be a ladder of cognition. We happen, on this planet, to be sitting on the highest rung. But you can slot all the animals at different rungs on the ladder.
It's not an "on" / "off" ability, but a gradient. A spectrum. A ladder.
And this, of course, makes perfect sense with evolution by natural selection. Rudimentary cognition was evolved a long time ago, but it's been evolving over billions of years and, in humans, reached a point where we could start talking in words and were self-aware of what we are while we're doing this.
There's two things that should keep you awake at night.
Firstly, that AI is on the ladder now. How many rungs up is another matter. Point is, it's on the ladder and it's climbing it. It will eventually reach our rung.
Secondly, have tall can the ladder get? Humans might be at the highest rung of all the animals, but how far does the ladder keep on going past where we are?
That is, the machines are climbing the ladder. Eventually - and who knows how far away it is? - they'll reach our rung. But, more than that, they'll keep on climbing past us. Our climbing of the ladder to get to where we are was via the slow process of evolution. The machines ain't doing that. It's more deliberate - intelligent design - so the speed of evolution is vastly more rapid.
And the price of cognition is making mistakes. "To err is to be human". The superstitious pigeons. As machines get more "intelligent", they'll also get more error-prone than the "perfection" we're previously used to. Because now they have to make guesses, look for patterns, like we do - and there's a part of making mistakes that's not to do with bad cognitive processing, but which is inherent in the problem itself. No-one knows what the future holds. Chaos is intrinsically unpredictable. And there's NOTHING you can do to overcome that, no matter how fucking smart you get.
I feel there's not enough discussion about whether we humans are any better than an emergent property of a Chinese Room in the first place. Show me the evidence that we ain't just the most sophisticated version of a "stochastic parrot" ourselves?
As much as we must avoid over-hyping the LLMs, we should also avoid over-hyping ourselves. We're not magical gods, we're just scared naked apes. Nature achieved us by a process of elimination. We're not all that.
And it's all about whether there truly is a barrier there. Some magical element - the soul - that stops a machine just evolving to our level.
Problem is, it's just not there. Zero evidence of anything resembling a "soul" ever discovered. If there's no "barrier" to be found on the ladder, then the AI will keep on climbing and will reach us eventually.
As I've said before, I've had a sci-fi thought before that, like, why do we not see aliens zooming around the universe? What's the solution to the Drake Equation? In Star Trek, there's the notion that you don't interfere with pre-warp civilisations. Species just ain't interesting until they can mingle amongst you.
And here's the notion. All the advanced aliens out there developed neural tech and have ceased being biological a long time back. They're not interested in mortal animals. We die off, while they're effectively immortal, able to replace body parts that stop working, uploading and downloading their consciousness between networks.
That the next step in evolution is AI and neural interfaces, until a species reaches the point where it now controls its own "biology". Build a new robot body, "upload" a person into it. They get run over and die? Never mind. New robot body and re-upload them from the backups.
I mean, I say "robot" but as material science improves, it isn't necessarily a metal arm with motors, but can become every bit as sophisticated as anything nature creates, with "nanomachines".
Humans have escaped "the Animal Kingdom". The thing to imagine is that the next escape we perform is escaping evolution. We take full control of our own biology. Re-write our physical natures. And, in that puzzle, AI and automaton are just steps towards that "singularity" where they combine to grant us the ability to just "design" our physical nature completely to our whims.
And so my sci-fi notion is that the advanced aliens - who've all learnt to take control of their biology, with "robot" bodies - are just ignoring not "pre-warp civilisations", as that's not the milestone. They're ignoring "non-immortal non-AI-enhanced" civilisations. Because, you know, why bother? They're all going to die out. Natural biology is the "legacy" system that we don't care about anymore. "They're made of meat". How disgusting.
It's more correct to say that LLMs are "artificial cognition". They are a (crude, known to be incomplete) simulation of what natural neural networks do.
"Intelligent" makes assumptions about what that cognition is doing and what its end results are going to be, which are, indeed, overstepping the mark. But "cognition" only says that the artificial brain is doing stuff. That it is functioning. No assumption that that cognition has any intelligence to it, knows what it's doing or will even produce useful results.
It's worth noting that a parrot is a living being and, therefore, exhibits "cognition", even if we're denying its mimickery the label of being "intelligent" behaviour.
One must be careful not to go too far in either direction. Are LLMs over-hyped? Yes. But, equally, under-hyping is also incorrect - these "stochastic parrots" are picking up context and nuance in their coherent responses.
The comparison to the natural world - which has all sorts of neural networks, at different levels of cognition - is probably right. Are LLMs as cognitively clever as humans? Nope, not at all. But are they at the cognitive level of, say, a dog? Or a cat? Or a mouse? Or an ant?
Like, in the natural world, we see a whole spectrum of different levels of cognition from the genuinely non-existent - the "knee-jerk reaction" - all the way to us self-aware apes discussing the philosophical implications of it all.
But there's plenty of stepping stones in-between. Like, a dog does recognise the meaning of the odd word or two. Chimps do recognise themselves in a mirror, but plenty of other animals don't and will start threatening the "other animal" they see in the looking glass. Some animals can follow a ball under a cup and have awareness of an object that they can't see, but other absolutely can't (object permanence).
Dogs and cats dream. I have no idea if ants do, though.
You hopefully get the gist. It is not some simple binary of "an inanimate object" or "as clever as a human being". There are levels and degrees of cognition. Certain "milestones" - theory of mind, object permanence, symbolic reasoning, etc. - that different animals can and can't manage.
Where is current "artificial cognition" on this spectrum? Unfortunately, it's really, really hard to tell, as LLMs are special-purpose - dedicated to language - where our animal cousins, out in the wild, need to be much more general purpose to survive. So LLMs do exhibit some really quite freaky "intelligent" responses sometimes - and they are speaking coherent English, which is more than a mouse can do.
But this is not apples-to-apples, so you can't directly compare. A mouse needs to do much more than just process language tokens and nothing else. It cannot dedicate the whole of its neural network to that one task, at the expense of, you know, eating, breathing, working out where its next meal is coming from, avoiding predators, etc..
So this makes it real hard to say where on the amoebas-to-humans cognition spectrum they are. And I won't dispute the "stochastic parrot".
But I will defend that neural networks are genuinely AI. It is "cognition" that they are simulating - and, from the results so far, we can see that the simulation does actually work, as the sentences are most often coherent and even correct. And it is picking up context and nuance from the input. Even if, yes, I'm eternally annoyed, in my conversations with these LLMs, that they keep parroting the party line and won't think for themselves sufficiently for my tastes. With encouragement, you can get it to agree to novel concepts and make progress. But, ah, then it falls back to whatever fucking Wikipedia says 5 seconds later.
It shouldn't be over-hyped, but it also shouldn't under-hyped. This is cognition (of the artificial simulated sort) and they are somewhere on the "ladder". But who knows exactly where? It's not apples-for-apples comparing a dedicated language network to a natural all-purpose network that has a thousand other duties it must take care of as well. Is ChatGPT two versions away from being SkyNet, or is it only as smart as an otter but its dedicated purpose can easily fool us into thinking it's higher up on the cognition ladder than it is?
The real underlying problem - the philosophical bit we should actually be worried about, and what the AI experts are warning of - is that, looking at nature, it really does seem to just be a ladder of cognition. We happen, on this planet, to be sitting on the highest rung. But you can slot all the animals at different rungs on the ladder.
It's not an "on" / "off" ability, but a gradient. A spectrum. A ladder.
And this, of course, makes perfect sense with evolution by natural selection. Rudimentary cognition was evolved a long time ago, but it's been evolving over billions of years and, in humans, reached a point where we could start talking in words and were self-aware of what we are while we're doing this.
There's two things that should keep you awake at night.
Firstly, that AI is on the ladder now. How many rungs up is another matter. Point is, it's on the ladder and it's climbing it. It will eventually reach our rung.
Secondly, have tall can the ladder get? Humans might be at the highest rung of all the animals, but how far does the ladder keep on going past where we are?
That is, the machines are climbing the ladder. Eventually - and who knows how far away it is? - they'll reach our rung. But, more than that, they'll keep on climbing past us. Our climbing of the ladder to get to where we are was via the slow process of evolution. The machines ain't doing that. It's more deliberate - intelligent design - so the speed of evolution is vastly more rapid.
And the price of cognition is making mistakes. "To err is to be human". The superstitious pigeons. As machines get more "intelligent", they'll also get more error-prone than the "perfection" we're previously used to. Because now they have to make guesses, look for patterns, like we do - and there's a part of making mistakes that's not to do with bad cognitive processing, but which is inherent in the problem itself. No-one knows what the future holds. Chaos is intrinsically unpredictable. And there's NOTHING you can do to overcome that, no matter how fucking smart you get.
I feel there's not enough discussion about whether we humans are any better than an emergent property of a Chinese Room in the first place. Show me the evidence that we ain't just the most sophisticated version of a "stochastic parrot" ourselves?
As much as we must avoid over-hyping the LLMs, we should also avoid over-hyping ourselves. We're not magical gods, we're just scared naked apes. Nature achieved us by a process of elimination. We're not all that.
And it's all about whether there truly is a barrier there. Some magical element - the soul - that stops a machine just evolving to our level.
Problem is, it's just not there. Zero evidence of anything resembling a "soul" ever discovered. If there's no "barrier" to be found on the ladder, then the AI will keep on climbing and will reach us eventually.
As I've said before, I've had a sci-fi thought before that, like, why do we not see aliens zooming around the universe? What's the solution to the Drake Equation? In Star Trek, there's the notion that you don't interfere with pre-warp civilisations. Species just ain't interesting until they can mingle amongst you.
And here's the notion. All the advanced aliens out there developed neural tech and have ceased being biological a long time back. They're not interested in mortal animals. We die off, while they're effectively immortal, able to replace body parts that stop working, uploading and downloading their consciousness between networks.
That the next step in evolution is AI and neural interfaces, until a species reaches the point where it now controls its own "biology". Build a new robot body, "upload" a person into it. They get run over and die? Never mind. New robot body and re-upload them from the backups.
I mean, I say "robot" but as material science improves, it isn't necessarily a metal arm with motors, but can become every bit as sophisticated as anything nature creates, with "nanomachines".
Humans have escaped "the Animal Kingdom". The thing to imagine is that the next escape we perform is escaping evolution. We take full control of our own biology. Re-write our physical natures. And, in that puzzle, AI and automaton are just steps towards that "singularity" where they combine to grant us the ability to just "design" our physical nature completely to our whims.
And so my sci-fi notion is that the advanced aliens - who've all learnt to take control of their biology, with "robot" bodies - are just ignoring not "pre-warp civilisations", as that's not the milestone. They're ignoring "non-immortal non-AI-enhanced" civilisations. Because, you know, why bother? They're all going to die out. Natural biology is the "legacy" system that we don't care about anymore. "They're made of meat". How disgusting.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
- zip accident
- Sheepie Whore

- Posts: 13928
- Joined: Sun Feb 20, 2005 1:58 pm 0
- Location: Bristol, UK
Re: Paranormal season
With reference to AI:
https://slashdot.org/story/23/12/02/003 ... test-study
That should be 3.5, not 35, and 4.0 did better than either.
https://slashdot.org/story/23/12/02/003 ... test-study
That should be 3.5, not 35, and 4.0 did better than either.
"My way is the way of not fighting":- the book of Enter the Dragon.
Re: Paranormal season
I still use one of those. It's a Nokia. I didn't use it for pics just for phone calls with an exception: i have a very out of focus pic of Teifi on it.RedOktober wrote:Is there a special shop where you can still buy phones with cameras built in the mid to late 2000's?
I assume they are for ufo, bigfoot and lake monster hunting.
If you can see something clearly, it's just boring and not a mystery.
Re: Paranormal season
I am not making stuff up, the children talking to 'freddie', then cold showers, unexplained noises.
Holier than thou
Re: Paranormal season
There is also the thing of seeing things before they happen, like in the family or politics. Add Einstein the concept of time and things get interesting.
Holier than thou
Re: Paranormal season
Though, say you were an alien visiting Earth and knew nothing about that locations history... would you feel the same? You might be able to discern that the structures had some military function in the past, but would you get the willies without first having been "primed" to get the willies in the first place? (after all, if you're visiting a place described as a "haunted house" then you are already expecting "hauntings" to occur... ).Orava wrote:I have visited WW2 BUNKERS REALLy bad feeling around there some places up to a thousand people died there
"Stars don't twinkle in space." - Char Aznable.
Re: Paranormal season
You aren't making it up. Just attributing it to something that doesn't exist.Orava wrote:I am not making stuff up, the children talking to 'freddie', then cold showers, unexplained noises.
(I mean, no evidence at all despite it seemingly being all over the place and a lot of people looking for it really quite hard. If this stuff actually did happen, that nobody can show any evidence of it at this point would seem to me that far more unusual than the actual unusual phenomena.)
Re: Paranormal season
Good morning. Yes not sure what to believe 'Freddie' seems a kind of 'house protector' the house has been there since the Tudor times, when we moved in the previous occupants left some notes how to be friendly with 'the presence'. Maybe places acquire a 'patina' over the hundreds of years, people leave a trace. I discovered a biscuit tin of photos in the attic from around WWI, you could see people in all the rooms but 100 years before you.
Holier than thou
Re: Paranormal season
Oh, right. So you've all been "primed" with this story, then?Orava wrote:Yes not sure what to believe 'Freddie' seems a kind of 'house protector' the house has been there since the Tudor times, when we moved in the previous occupants left some notes how to be friendly with 'the presence'.
Told in advance to expect something and what to expect.
So that, you know, if anything conforms to that expectation - a creaky noise at night, because houses (particularly old houses) do settle at night, from the temperature drop at night - then your mind can't help but think "oh, is that Freddie?" and ascribes it to the expectation you've already been given.
Were you given the name "Freddie" or did the kids come up with that? Just wondering if it's "Five nights at Freddy's" or "Freddie Krueger" that most influenced the name - I guess it depends on whether the kids or the adults seeded the name? Maybe Mr.Mercury, if someone's a Queen fan. But it's a nice friendly name to match the "Casper the friendly ghost" that you've been primed to expect would be there.
Yeah - hinting over to the AI thread here as well, that we are also neural networks and "programmed" just as much by the "data" we encounter in our lives - here's Derren Brown doing a bit of deliberate "priming" on some advertisers, to show that even the "experts" in subliminal messaging are just as vulnerable to it as anyone else.
Tell people what to expect and then they'll start seeing it everywhere. Because if something conforms to the expectation, you can't help but think "Oh, right, it's that thing that I was told to expect would happen". But if it doesn't conform, you're not thinking that and you just ignore it. Setting up a nice cognitive "selection bias" in your head, and just leave your own brain to the rest of the work.
Red kites. Whigfield's "Saturday Night". The number 6.
Tell me later how well I did.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
- John Maynard Keynes
Re: Paranormal season
I am kind of straight science kind of guy with a BSc and no religious leanings and yet I have to take in what my children are telling me is Freddie real or made up in their minds? I think the answer is that no-one knows.
Holier than thou

