Dio wrote:I'm a million miles from an expert, but a lot of basic reaction stuff actually comes pretty quickly though, I'd have thought.
That was one of the original points I made.
Reaction times vary between "expected" and "unexpected".
It's a big difference.
I saw a science documentary on TV once where an Olympic runner - it was Linford Christie or Colin Jackson or someone like that - showed the difference in reaction time to the starter gun.
They hooked up the athletes to a machine to record their reaction precisely (milliseconds resolution) and when they did it in the usual fashion we see in the Olympics of preparing at the starting blocks and running at the sound of a starter gun, the reactions were amazingly quick. Tenths of a second or less.
But then, for comparison, they did the same test but where the starter gun was replaced with some loud noise (something that the runners wouldn't be expecting and haven't trained themselves to react to) and without going through the usual preparations.
The reactions dropped from milliseconds to nearly a whole second.
For the "unexpected stimulus", reactions slow down big-time that you can visibly see the hesitation.
You're right. Reactions - expected or unexpected - are fast.
But the two are in a different league time-wise. I can't find a good Google article on it that specifically talks about this but, if you look around, you'll find things that mention this difference (mostly about braking distances on cars).
The point I was generally trying to make is that if this is a genuine "happy slap" then the victim would be showing unexpected reaction times, not expected reaction times.
As I've stressed, this is not the be-all and end-all of my case that the clip is fake. Not at all. But it's one more cog in the machine that all points to it being faked.
It's a "probability" argument rather than a "true / false" argument.
But, basically, he appears to react too quickly to the slap for an unexpected reaction.
Take another look at the clip at the moment of giving the slap.
If you don't know someone's going to slap you then you would not even perceive someone raising their arm as a problem
UNTIL it actually very close to your face.
Because if you're not expecting a slap then you're not going to perceive someone raising their arm as unusual
until that point where it's clearly coming for you.
Take another look at the clip. He reacts too early.
He tenses up and starts reacting as the arm is
beginning to move upwards.
But at that point, if you're not expecting a slap, then you wouldn't interpret someone walking by moving their arm as an attack until it's close enough that it couldn't be anything else.
Okay, you could argue the reaction time is a judgement call.
But I have a trained eye for this sort of thing and it looks to me like the reaction is much too early for "unexpected".
But, as I say, it doesn't matter because I was never resting my case that it was a fake on that sole point anyway.
If you insisit I'm imagining things (but I assure you I have a trained eye and I'm not) then strike that point from the list. It doesn't matter: It's still a fake for another 20 or so other reasons I gave.
Perhaps I'm being too cynical here but I'm suspecting that I'm getting flak over this because some were taken in by the faked clip and because I presented such a strong "it's a fake, without any doubt" case.
I'm now being blamed "by proxy" for the fact that the fake clip suckered a few of you into believing it was genuine.
Or, in other words: "shut up, Klaxoncow, I believed / I want to believe that the clip was genuine and you're ruining that. So just shut up about it".
If so then note that I gladly will stop talking about it when people stop posting up replies that naturally insist that I have to reply once more to defend my position.
Or, in other words: "you first".

"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes