Happy slapper gets pwned

Inane baanter or words of wisdom - you decide...
Post Reply
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8446
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Post by KlaxonCow »

Moreso, the clip is a fake.

A fake.

The clip is a fake.

This extended discussion is irrelevent to that fact and doesn't change it.

Blaming me for something or another doesn't deflect from the fact that some of you were all too ready to pour hatred at the "happy slapping chav" that you possibly saw what you wanted to see and got taken in by a faked clip.

I mean, shoot the messenger, if you insist. But the message won't change:

It's a fake. :D


p.s. Regards the "average" comment, surely it depends on whether we're talking about a mean, mode or median average and the standard deviation of fighting prowess amongst the population, presuming a normal distribution of cases?

Or, of course, you could stop being a pedantic arse about it and take the colloquial use of the word "average" in the spirit intended :roll: :D
Last edited by KlaxonCow on Wed Apr 19, 2006 12:56 pm 0, edited 2 times in total.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
stealthbanana
Baaaaaa!
Baaaaaa!
Posts: 2805
Joined: Wed Nov 09, 2005 11:59 pm 0
Location: Over Here.

Post by stealthbanana »

KlaxonCow wrote:Moreso, the clip is a fake.

A fake.

The clip is a fake.

This extended discussion is irrelevent to that fact and doesn't change it.

Blaming me for something or another doesn't deflect from the fact that some of you were all too ready to pour hatred at the "happy slapping chav" that you possibly saw what you wanted to see and got taken in by a faked clip.

I mean, shoot the messenger, if you insist. But the message won't change:

It's a fake. :D
So you reckon its a fake then?

:)
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8446
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Post by KlaxonCow »

stealthbanana wrote:So you reckon its a fake then?

:)
Not sure. Might be. :wink:
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
RiK
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 16092
Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
PSN: Dr Thumpy
Location: The Shire
Contact:

Post by RiK »

KlaxonCow wrote:But when hit for no reason in the street totally unexpected: You would definitely pause and assess the situation. You would be shocked and thinking "what the fuck?!?" (even if you don't say it).
Firstly, whilst I do agree that clip is probably a fake I have to disagree with the above comment.

The single most important thing I teach consistently is that to be effective in self defence you must learn to re-program your body's natural response to a threat. We use the term BAR, Body Alarm Reaction, to describe the very specific type of shock a human body experiences when attacked. Most people will freeze, cover their head and assume a foetal position. I teach people that the most important thing is to react immediately and proactively. With appropriate regular training it becomes completely natural to respond first and figure our what happened later.

I can verify this from first hand experience on many occasions.
User avatar
RiK
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 16092
Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
PSN: Dr Thumpy
Location: The Shire
Contact:

Post by RiK »

George_Bray wrote:One said that bone-on-bone (knuckle to jaw) solid/hard connection will KO most people but my current Sensei disagrees with this. He has always been taught soft-on-hard surface (ooerrr missus!) eg. Palm hand to a boney area (chin etc.) he feels this is far more effective and will do less damage to your body. He also adds that alot of boxers for example can break their hands (or suffer serious damage to them during each fight!). Both Sensei's were 2nd Dans so I'm sure there's credibility in both theories.

Rik, what's your take on this, as I fully trust your judgement? :-D
I agree with respect to minimising the risk of hurting yourself. I rarely hit bony areas with a closed fist. The human hand is a fragile tool and the likelyhood of breaking it is a real risk. Break your hand and you've just severely restricted your options as you've taken your primary tool out of the fight, not a good idea. That being said, if it was the only shot available to me, I'd still take it and worry about it afterwards.

As for the knockout issue, it depends entirely on the type of knockout (physical shock, nervous system or TCM pressure points). Different areas of the body respond differently to different types of stimulus.

I've spent years studying the application of traditional chinese medicine as applied to the martial arts. It is exactly the same science that an acupuncturist uses. They use combinations of vital points to balance out or enhance the flow of energy (chi/ki) in the body to improve health and vitality. Other combinations of points have the opposite effect and those are the ones we use in the martial arts.

It's serious stuff and it very definitely works. It's not brute force, you don't need to hit like a boxer, you just need to hit them the right way.

Coincidentally as it's relevant to this thread, a simple punch to the point of the chin *will* KO someone quite easily if it's on the right angle (which incidentally isn't uphill like a boxer's uppercut). I've witnessed many a 'lucky shot' from an untrained person do just that, most of the time unintentionally.
User avatar
aureole
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7150
Joined: Fri May 24, 2002 12:35 pm 0

Post by aureole »

KlaxonCow wrote: p.s. Regards the "average" comment, surely it depends on whether we're talking about a mean, mode or median average and the standard deviation of fighting prowess amongst the population, presuming a normal distribution of cases?

Or, of course, you could stop being a pedantic arse about it and take the colloquial use of the word "average" in the spirit intended :roll: :D
No, it's not the definition of average I object to (and being a pedantic arse I'd like to point out the mean, mode and median are identical for points drawn from a Gaussian (normal) distribution). You made the statement that since the average person couldn't do that, that it the clip wasn't genuine, and I think that's a specious argument. Partly since we're looking at a sample size of one anyway (as Gravy pointed out), and partly since there's a number of plausible mechanisms by which the a priori probability of retailiatory action given the relative fighting ability/aggression of the person concerned.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8446
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Post by KlaxonCow »

RiK wrote:
KlaxonCow wrote:But when hit for no reason in the street totally unexpected: You would definitely pause and assess the situation. You would be shocked and thinking "what the fuck?!?" (even if you don't say it).
Firstly, whilst I do agree that clip is probably a fake I have to disagree with the above comment.

The single most important thing I teach consistently is that to be effective in self defence you must learn to re-program your body's natural response to a threat. We use the term BAR, Body Alarm Reaction, to describe the very specific type of shock a human body experiences when attacked. Most people will freeze, cover their head and assume a foetal position. I teach people that the most important thing is to react immediately and proactively. With appropriate regular training it becomes completely natural to respond first and figure our what happened later.

I can verify this from first hand experience on many occasions.
Yes. Totally. I agree with you.

That's what people should be taught to do.

But what people naturally do, as you've confirmed, is not act immediately and proactively.

That's what my point about the clip was:

He is not acting naturally. "Naturally" would be, as you say and I was trying to say, to pause, take stock, assess what's going on, etc.

I'm not saying he should act that way, if he wants to be a "Jedi Master of Kung Fu". You're the expert on that and I defer completely to your expert opinon: He shouldn't do that and should react proactively.

In my original post, I was only observing what the guy does in the video which is "unnatural" and that indicates that the clip is a fake.

I wasn't giving him "top tips" on how to react, just noting that his reaction was not the standard natural reaction people (without SAS or Judo training) naturally do.

That's the whole point. His reaction isn't natural.

Therefore, it was one more "clue that this clip is a fake".

Admittedly, there is the possibility that he has had martial arts training and that's why he reacts immediately and proactively...

,..BUT - and you'd be the better expert than me to confirm this - when I look at his punch and his kick afterwards, that just is NOT saying "SAS trained Jedi Kung Fu Master of Supreme Fighting Skills" to me.

I don't see "technique" (well, only acting technique to fake it all) in what he does afterwards to suggest that his "unnatural reaction" is due to several decades of martial arts training.
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
gravy
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 19572
Joined: Wed May 01, 2002 1:28 pm 0
Location: The Other Place

Post by gravy »

<eiger>YOUR IN TEST!</eiger>
User avatar
RiK
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 16092
Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
PSN: Dr Thumpy
Location: The Shire
Contact:

Post by RiK »

To reiterate, I agree that clip looks faked, I've already said so above. As you've pointed out there are plenty of clues.
KlaxonCow wrote:In my original post, I was only observing what the guy does in the video which is "unnatural" and that indicates that the clip is a fake.
It would be a perfectly natural reaction from most of my friends though - the big clue to me is that actually he's far too nice about his response ;)
KlaxonCow wrote:Admittedly, there is the possibility that he has had martial arts training and that's why he reacts immediately and proactively...
A-ha!
KlaxonCow wrote:,..BUT - and you'd be the better expert than me to confirm this - when I look at his punch and his kick afterwards, that just is NOT saying "SAS trained Jedi Kung Fu Master of Supreme Fighting Skills" to me.

I don't see "technique" (well, only acting technique to fake it all) in what he does afterwards to suggest that his "unnatural reaction" is due to several decades of martial arts training.
I'm not suggesting for one minute that the guy in the video was trained as I don't think he was. He was far too passive for starters, but..

When you're under BAR, fine motor skills go right out of the window and often even quite a skilled fighter looks like a spanner. I've seen loads of street fights and I know for sure that some of the guys had trained yet when it comes down to it you would be hard pressed to tell if you didn't know them... (spanners!)
User avatar
Dio
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 18887
Joined: Mon May 31, 2004 1:08 pm 0
Location: Newcastle UK

Post by Dio »

I'm a million miles from an expert, but a lot of basic reaction stuff actually comes pretty quickly though, I'd have thought.

I'm sure if I hit someone I wouldn't look much like a martial arts expert, having done 3 years of karate 15 years ago, but I learned an awful lot of odd basic things, like reactions and balance, that I know I still have a good chunk of now. I found at the time it's astonishing how quickly you can be back on your feet when you're knocked over, for example, if getting back on your feet is a priority (and it bloody well should be most of the time). It's also amazing how quickly you think of your elbows, and there is no doubt in my mind if I got into a fight I would be going for it 100%. There's no such thing as attempting to hit someone if you're not going for a seriously maiming blow.

Of course, I've still not been in a fight with anyone since I left school so I've no idea how effective I would be. And I hope never to find out.
User avatar
aureole
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 7150
Joined: Fri May 24, 2002 12:35 pm 0

Post by aureole »

I think the only way to settle this is to film KlaxonCow trying to slap Rik.

Under laboratory conditions, like.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8446
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Post by KlaxonCow »

aureole wrote:You made the statement that since the average person couldn't do that, that it the clip wasn't genuine, and I think that's a specious argument.
Actually, no. I never made any such statement.

My original post contained numerous points that all pointed to it being a fake.

In reply, someone took one of my points and disagreed with it.

Ever since we've been discussing that one point.

But I never stated it was a fake because of that one point alone.

I stated it was a fake because of nearly 20 separate points.

Including, for example, the simple fact that you can see his punch and kick don't make contact right there in front of your face. Which is the only real point that needs to be pushed to show it's a fake. I added the rest for fun. :D

I never stated that it was a fake solely because of that single point about his unnatural reactions.

I observed - and have now had experts in fighting technique and dealing with fights confirm it - that it was unnatural reaction for that one point.

Admittedly, "unnatural reaction" alone is no case for proving it's a fake.

But my case for that included nearly 20 points which indicated - some by "high probability" that it was likely a fake (such as unnatural reaction and camerawork) and others by direct observation (e.g. his punch and kick do not make contact, the guy reacts to being kicked before he is kicked, etc.) - that it was a fake.

I made a full and exhaustive case from 14 or so completely different angles, making 20 or so points which indicated it was a fake.

Which it is. It is a fake.

My case never rested on this sole point of an unnatural reaction providing a high probablity that it wasn't real.

That was just because someone picked out that one point to disagree with it (while stating, by the way, "I agree with most of that" and "yes, it is a fake").

Please.

I'm being given that "internet treatment" here:

1. I make a massive post, full of points and observations.

2. Someone picks out one point as dubious (because, yes, I fully admit that it's a "probability" rather than "certainty" kind of argument: It's just "unlikely" that his unnatural reaction would be real. It does not, I fully agree, prove anything in itself or alone).

3. Everyone acts as if proving this one point wrong - while ignoring the 20 or so other points I also made - proves my whole argument is wrong.

Typical internet argument.


Einstein published his General Theory of Relativity. Along comes a fellow physicist and asks "so, Einstein, who do you reckon is going to win the grand national?". Einstein picks the wrong horse.

Clearly, because Einstein was wrong on this one point, every single thing he's ever stated in his whole entire life is also wrong "by association".


Nevermind.

At least, I've filled up my internet argument bingo card finally. :lol: :D
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
User avatar
RiK
Sheepie Whore
Sheepie Whore
Posts: 16092
Joined: Tue Apr 23, 2002 11:32 pm 0
XBL Gamertag: Dr Olpin
PSN: Dr Thumpy
Location: The Shire
Contact:

Post by RiK »

KlaxonCow wrote:Including, for example, the simple fact that you can see his punch and kick don't make contact right there in front of your face. Which is the only real point that needs to be pushed to show it's a fake.
I don't actually agree with that point, simply because I don't think the frame rate or resolution of the video is sufficient to see that clearly.

It certainly *sounds* like contact was made and the physical reactions following both the initial slap and the retaliatory punch are fairly consistent with someone who had been hit. Regarding the 'KO' punch, it's quite usual for the knees to buckle and someone fall on the spot, especially if it wasn't a total knockout which is highly likely.

There are still plenty of things which suggest it was fake, but I don't think it's as black and white as you suggest.
User avatar
KlaxonCow
Baaaaaaa!
Baaaaaaa!
Posts: 8446
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2002 3:46 am 0
Location: A large grassy field.

Post by KlaxonCow »

Dio wrote:I'm a million miles from an expert, but a lot of basic reaction stuff actually comes pretty quickly though, I'd have thought.
That was one of the original points I made.

Reaction times vary between "expected" and "unexpected".

It's a big difference.

I saw a science documentary on TV once where an Olympic runner - it was Linford Christie or Colin Jackson or someone like that - showed the difference in reaction time to the starter gun.

They hooked up the athletes to a machine to record their reaction precisely (milliseconds resolution) and when they did it in the usual fashion we see in the Olympics of preparing at the starting blocks and running at the sound of a starter gun, the reactions were amazingly quick. Tenths of a second or less.

But then, for comparison, they did the same test but where the starter gun was replaced with some loud noise (something that the runners wouldn't be expecting and haven't trained themselves to react to) and without going through the usual preparations.

The reactions dropped from milliseconds to nearly a whole second.

For the "unexpected stimulus", reactions slow down big-time that you can visibly see the hesitation.

You're right. Reactions - expected or unexpected - are fast.

But the two are in a different league time-wise. I can't find a good Google article on it that specifically talks about this but, if you look around, you'll find things that mention this difference (mostly about braking distances on cars).

The point I was generally trying to make is that if this is a genuine "happy slap" then the victim would be showing unexpected reaction times, not expected reaction times.


As I've stressed, this is not the be-all and end-all of my case that the clip is fake. Not at all. But it's one more cog in the machine that all points to it being faked.


It's a "probability" argument rather than a "true / false" argument.

But, basically, he appears to react too quickly to the slap for an unexpected reaction.

Take another look at the clip at the moment of giving the slap.

If you don't know someone's going to slap you then you would not even perceive someone raising their arm as a problem UNTIL it actually very close to your face.

Because if you're not expecting a slap then you're not going to perceive someone raising their arm as unusual until that point where it's clearly coming for you.

Take another look at the clip. He reacts too early.

He tenses up and starts reacting as the arm is beginning to move upwards.

But at that point, if you're not expecting a slap, then you wouldn't interpret someone walking by moving their arm as an attack until it's close enough that it couldn't be anything else.

Okay, you could argue the reaction time is a judgement call.

But I have a trained eye for this sort of thing and it looks to me like the reaction is much too early for "unexpected".

But, as I say, it doesn't matter because I was never resting my case that it was a fake on that sole point anyway.

If you insisit I'm imagining things (but I assure you I have a trained eye and I'm not) then strike that point from the list. It doesn't matter: It's still a fake for another 20 or so other reasons I gave.


Perhaps I'm being too cynical here but I'm suspecting that I'm getting flak over this because some were taken in by the faked clip and because I presented such a strong "it's a fake, without any doubt" case.

I'm now being blamed "by proxy" for the fact that the fake clip suckered a few of you into believing it was genuine.

Or, in other words: "shut up, Klaxoncow, I believed / I want to believe that the clip was genuine and you're ruining that. So just shut up about it".

If so then note that I gladly will stop talking about it when people stop posting up replies that naturally insist that I have to reply once more to defend my position.

Or, in other words: "you first". :lol: :D
"Words ought to be a little wild - for they are assaults of thought on the unthinking."
- John Maynard Keynes
random
Baaaa!
Baaaa!
Posts: 725
Joined: Sat Sep 20, 2003 4:48 pm 0

Post by random »

KlaxonCow wrote:stuff
A friendly suggestion as drilled into me by my English teacher so long ago. Once you have finished writing go through and delete every other word. Modify, without adding, to make sure it makes sense. You'll find your arguments aren't as obscured by random text.
Post Reply